Could Haditha be just the tip of the mass grave? The corpses we have glimpsed, the grainy footage of the cadavers and the dead children; could these be just a few of many? Does the handiwork of America's army of the slums go further?
I remember clearly the first suspicions I had that murder most foul might be taking place in our name in Iraq. I was in the Baghdad mortuary, counting corpses, when one of the city's senior medical officials, an old friend, told me of his fears. "Everyone brings bodies here," he said. "But when the Americans bring bodies in, we are instructed that under no circumstances are we ever to do post-mortems. We were given to understand that this had already been done. Sometimes we'd get a piece of paper like this one with a body." And here the man handed me a U.S. military document showing with the hand-drawn outline of a man's body and the words "trauma wounds."
What kind of trauma is now being experienced in Iraq? Just who is doing the mass killing? Who is dumping so many bodies on garbage heaps? After Haditha, we are going to reshape our suspicions.
It's no good saying "a few bad apples." All occupation armies are corrupted. But do they all commit war crimes? The Algerians are still uncovering the mass graves left by the French paras who liquidated whole villages. We know of the rapist-killers of the Russian army in Chechnya.
We have all heard of Bloody Sunday. The Israelis sat and watched while their proxy Lebanese militia butchered and eviscerated its way through 1,700 Palestinians. And of course the words My Lai are now uttered again. Yes, the Nazis were much worse. And the Japanese. And the Croatian Ustashi. But this is us. This is our army. These young soldiers are our representatives in Iraq. And they have innocent blood on their hands.
I suspect part of the problem is that we never really cared about Iraqis, which is why we refused to count their dead. Once the Iraqis turned upon the army of occupation with their roadside bombs and suicide cars, they became Arab "gooks," the evil sub-humans whom the Americans once identified in Vietnam. Get a president to tell us that we are fighting evil and one day we will wake to find that a child has horns, a baby has cloven feet.
Remind yourself these people are Muslims and they can all become little Mohamed Attas. Killing a roomful of civilians is only a step further from all those promiscuous air strikes that we are told kill 'terrorists" but which all too often turn out to be a wedding party or -- as in Afghanistan -- a mixture of "terrorists" and children or, as we are soon to hear, no doubt, "terrorist children."
In a way, we reporters are also to blame. Unable to venture outside Baghdad -- or around Baghdad itself -- Iraq's vastness has fallen under a thick, all-consuming shadow. We might occasionally notice sparks in the night -- a Haditha or two in the desert -- but we remain meekly cataloguing the numbers of "terrorists" supposedly scored in remote corners of Mesopotamia. For fear of the insurgent's knife, we can no longer investigate. And the Americans like it that way.
I think it becomes a habit, this sort of thing. Already the horrors of Abu Ghraib are shrugged away. It was abuse, not torture. And then up pops a junior officer in the United States charged for killing an Iraqi army general by stuffing him upside down in a sleeping bag and sitting on his chest. And again, it gets few headlines. Who cares if another Iraqi bites the dust? Aren't they trying to kill our boys who are out there fighting terror.
For who can be held to account when we regard ourselves as the brightest, the most honorable of creatures, doing endless battle with the killers of Sept. 11 or July 7 because we love our country and our people -- but not other people -- so much. And so we dress ourselves up as Galahads, yes as Crusaders, and we tell those whose countries we invade that we are going to bring them democracy. I can't help wondering today how many of the innocents slaughtered in Haditha took the opportunity to vote in the Iraqi elections -- before their "liberators" murdered them
Sunday, June 04, 2006
George Washington Had It Right By Charley Reese
Have you ever thought how peaceful and prosperous we would be if our national leaders had followed the advice of George Washington in his "Farewell Address"?
For starters, we would not be hopelessly in debt, and there would not be so many Americans buried in national cemeteries and in distant lands. Nor would we be as hated as we are today in so many countries, where new polls show people not only dislike American foreign policy and the American government, but are now deciding they don't like the American people.
Washington's recommended policy can be summed up as armed neutrality, the same policy Switzerland practices. While the rest of the world participated in a slaughterhouse during the 20th century, the Swiss remained at peace.
Washington was a very wise man. He said that no country can be trusted beyond its own self-interests. He said that habitual friendship toward a foreign country is as dangerous as habitual enmity. The policy of America should be trade with all but entangling alliances with nobody. The quarrels and vendettas in other parts of the world were none of our business, he said. As far as trade goes, all countries should be treated equal, with no favors granted to any of them.
He warned against foreign influence, calling it a poison to republican government. While he was no doubt thinking of the French, his advice applies to Israel. No foreign country should be allowed to influence American policy because that country will always seek to influence policy to favor its interests, not ours. If we followed Washington's advice, the only thing we would be sending to the Middle East would be oil tankers and tourists.
We could build a military force that could deter attacks on this country for a fraction of the cost we spend on trying to maintain an empire with about 745 military bases in 120 foreign countries. The only people who might attack us are a gang of terrorists, and, of course, our massive military machine is not equipped to deal with them.
As for domestic policy, Washington said the best way to preserve the union was to obey the Constitution and to never tolerate any branch of government usurping the Constitution's power. He said that a republican form of government required a virtuous people, and since religion is the best way to instill virtue in the masses, anybody who was an enemy of religion was an enemy of republican government.
All of that is pointless now, because we no longer have a republic — or a virtuous population, for that matter. We have an empire. We have a federal government that does nothing more than pay lip service to the Constitution, if that. Elections are decided by money, not by the people. Greed, self-indulgence and commercial entertainment seem to be the main motivations of a goodly number of our people. We will, as all empires have, bleed ourselves in foreign wars and domestic tyranny until we collapse. President Bush is a heck of a lot closer to Nero than he is to George Washington.
Too bad, because we could be such a happy place if we had sense enough to mind our own business and to elect men and women who would obey the Constitution. We have no legal authority, no moral authority and certainly no divine authority to interfere with the internal affairs of any other nation. It should not matter to us what kind of governments other people have or what their cultures are. There is nothing in the Constitution to authorize the federal government to tax Americans and then write checks to foreign countries. There is nothing in the Constitution that authorizes the president to take us to war. That is a power reserved exclusively to Congress. The Constitution also requires a warrant based on probable cause before the government can spy on us or search our homes and businesses.
Americans ought to read their Constitution, if for no other reason than to see what kind of government they are missing. It's written in very plain English and is easy to understand.
For starters, we would not be hopelessly in debt, and there would not be so many Americans buried in national cemeteries and in distant lands. Nor would we be as hated as we are today in so many countries, where new polls show people not only dislike American foreign policy and the American government, but are now deciding they don't like the American people.
Washington's recommended policy can be summed up as armed neutrality, the same policy Switzerland practices. While the rest of the world participated in a slaughterhouse during the 20th century, the Swiss remained at peace.
Washington was a very wise man. He said that no country can be trusted beyond its own self-interests. He said that habitual friendship toward a foreign country is as dangerous as habitual enmity. The policy of America should be trade with all but entangling alliances with nobody. The quarrels and vendettas in other parts of the world were none of our business, he said. As far as trade goes, all countries should be treated equal, with no favors granted to any of them.
He warned against foreign influence, calling it a poison to republican government. While he was no doubt thinking of the French, his advice applies to Israel. No foreign country should be allowed to influence American policy because that country will always seek to influence policy to favor its interests, not ours. If we followed Washington's advice, the only thing we would be sending to the Middle East would be oil tankers and tourists.
We could build a military force that could deter attacks on this country for a fraction of the cost we spend on trying to maintain an empire with about 745 military bases in 120 foreign countries. The only people who might attack us are a gang of terrorists, and, of course, our massive military machine is not equipped to deal with them.
As for domestic policy, Washington said the best way to preserve the union was to obey the Constitution and to never tolerate any branch of government usurping the Constitution's power. He said that a republican form of government required a virtuous people, and since religion is the best way to instill virtue in the masses, anybody who was an enemy of religion was an enemy of republican government.
All of that is pointless now, because we no longer have a republic — or a virtuous population, for that matter. We have an empire. We have a federal government that does nothing more than pay lip service to the Constitution, if that. Elections are decided by money, not by the people. Greed, self-indulgence and commercial entertainment seem to be the main motivations of a goodly number of our people. We will, as all empires have, bleed ourselves in foreign wars and domestic tyranny until we collapse. President Bush is a heck of a lot closer to Nero than he is to George Washington.
Too bad, because we could be such a happy place if we had sense enough to mind our own business and to elect men and women who would obey the Constitution. We have no legal authority, no moral authority and certainly no divine authority to interfere with the internal affairs of any other nation. It should not matter to us what kind of governments other people have or what their cultures are. There is nothing in the Constitution to authorize the federal government to tax Americans and then write checks to foreign countries. There is nothing in the Constitution that authorizes the president to take us to war. That is a power reserved exclusively to Congress. The Constitution also requires a warrant based on probable cause before the government can spy on us or search our homes and businesses.
Americans ought to read their Constitution, if for no other reason than to see what kind of government they are missing. It's written in very plain English and is easy to understand.
Normalizing the Unthinkable - John Pilger, Robert Fisk, Charlie Glass, and Seymour Hersh on the failure of the world's press
The late journalist Edward R. Murrow might well have been rolling in his grave on April 21. That's because Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice gave a lecture that day in Washington, DC to journalists at the Department of State's official Edward R. Murrow Program for Journalists.
For the Bush administration to use the memory of a person who stood up to government propaganda is ironic to say the least. Secretary Rice told the assembled journalists that "without a free press to report on the activities of government, to ask questions of officials, to be a place where citizens can express themselves, democracy simply couldn't work."
One week earlier in New York City, Columbia University hosted a panel on the state of the world's media that would have been more in Murrow's style than the State Department-run symposium. Reporter and filmmaker John Pilger, British Middle East correspondent for the Independent Robert Fisk, freelance reporter Charlie Glass, and investigative journalist for the New Yorker Seymour Hersh appeared together at this April 14 event.
Before the afternoon panel began, I met up with John Pilger at his hotel. He'd just flown in from London and was only in New York for the panel before flying to Caracas, Venezuela the next day. A journalist for over 30 years, Pilger has reported from Vietnam, Cambodia, East Timor, Palestine, and Iraq--to name a few of the countries to which his investigative reporting and filmmaking had taken him.
Pilger told me that he'd never been as concerned about the state of the media as he was today. "I think there’s a lot of reasons to be very concerned about the information or the lack of information that we get. There's never been such an interest, more than an interest, almost an obsession, in controlling what journalists have to say."
Despite the fact that the war in Iraq is reported daily in most U.S. newspapers and networks around the world, Pilger didn't think the world's press accurately conveyed the reality of life for Iraqi civilians. "We get the illusion that we are seeing what might be happening in Iraq. But what we're getting is a massive censorship by omission; so much is being left out," he said. "We have a situation in Iraq where well over 100,000 civilians have been killed and we have virtually no pictures. The control of that by the Pentagon has been quite brilliant. And as a result we have no idea of the extent of civilians suffering in that country."
I asked Pilger what the untold story of Iraq was that's just not getting through. "Well, the untold story of Iraq should be obvious," Pilger said. "But it never is. The untold story of Vietnam was that it was an invasion and that huge numbers of civilians were killed. And in effect it was a war against civilians and that was never told and that's exactly true of Iraq."
With the majority of the world's press holed up behind 4.5 miles of concrete barrier in the green zone, it seems impossible for the standard of reporting to improve anytime in the near future. I asked Pilger if he blamed journalists for not wanting to put their lives at risk? "No, I can’t," he said. "But I don’t see the point of being in the green zone. I don't see the point of wearing a flak jacket and standing in a hotel in a fortress guarded by an invader.
"But there have been journalists--and others--who have actually gone with the insurgents; who have reported about them. One of them, for instance, is a young woman named Jo Wilding, a British human rights worker. She was in Fallujah all through that first attack in 2004. Jo Wilding's dispatches were some of the most extraordinary I've read, but they were never published anywhere."
Pilger said the mainstream press needs to get over its hang up of "our man in Baghdad" and prioritize whatever information can be obtained by whoever is brave enough or has the best contacts. "There are sources of information for what is happening inside Iraq. Most of them are on the web. I think those who give a damn in the mainstream really have to look at those sources and surrender their prejudice about them and say we need that reporter's work because he or she has told us something we can't possibly get ourselves. And I think that's the only way we will really serve the public."
We had talked too long and had to quickly jump in a cab to make it to the panel on time. The hall was packed with university students, professors, and the public.
Charlie Glass
The event quickly got underway with Charlie Glass as the first speaker. A former ABC America correspondent in the Middle East, Glass drew laughs from the crowd when comparing his experience to the other panelists. "When I began journalism I approached it in the way a lot of young naive people do, in that it was a vocation, a higher calling to tell the truth. My three colleagues up here have managed to do that throughout their careers. I tried very hard to do that throughout my career...but I worked for an American network. It's not easy," joked Glass.
Glass spoke about the censorship he had encountered as an American TV reporter covering the Middle East, referring to a story he filed during the Israeli invasion of Lebanon in 1982. There had been rumors of Israeli Shin Bath death squads murdering Lebanese civilians in the South and Glass and his crew had managed to film the evidence behind these killings. "We nailed this story. We folded one of the death squads. We got to the palace where they had assassinated a man half an hour after he had been killed. We filmed it. We filmed the eyewitness. We filmed UN soldiers, who had seen the same things, discussing it," recalled Glass.
"ABC news didn’t broadcast it. But they won't tell you they're not going to broadcast it because they're afraid of losing advertising. They won't tell you they won't broadcast it because they're afraid of the public reaction. They tell you they just didn't have room that night or the next night or the next night. And that's just the way it is. That is why very few people in this country have any idea what’s going on in the Middle East."
Glass believes this kind of censorship has led to a chasm of misunderstanding within the U.S. public. "You don't understand what's been going on in Iraq because you've been lied to again. Just like you were in Vietnam. Just like you were in Lebanon and just like you were in the West Bank and Gaza," he said.
"Nobody has a clue why things went wrong in Iraq. Well, I’ll tell you why. They were always going to go wrong in Iraq. It wasn't because Bremer screwed up. It wasn't because the U.S. pilfered the Iraqi treasury, which is true. It wasn't because some soldiers misbehaved and shot some people in cars. It was because it could never go right in Iraq," Glass insisted. "The U.S. was not trusted by any Iraqi because the U.S. history in Iraq was so reprehensible--from the betrayal of the Kurds in 1975 when Henry Kissinger sold them out and they were massacred in the tens of thousands by Saddam, from the time they aided Saddam during the Iran/Iraq war, from the time they betrayed the Kurdish and Shia rebellions in 1991, from the sanctions regime that followed.
"Who would trust a power to liberate them who had already behaved like that? It isn't a question of what happened after; it’s a question of what happened before. We had an obligation to tell what happened before and we didn't," Glass said, before pausing to take a moment. "I've lost my vocation. I actually don't really like this profession anymore," Glass said regrettably.
Robert Fisk
Next to speak was Middle East correspondent Robert Fisk, arguably the world's most experienced Western reporter in the region. Fisk pulled out a copy of the New York Times and spread it out on the lectern. "This is from this morning's paper: Al-Qaeda's man in Iraq gets encouragement from HQ," Fisk read aloud. "An interior minister official said, officials said, the American military said, the Iraqi government said, some American officials here observed, and some military officials have said, two American intelligence officials said, one Pakistani official said, and I've only got to column two," Fisk exclaimed. "I've always believed that your major newspaper should be called 'American Officials Say.' Then you can just scrap all the reporting and have the Pentagon talking directly."
Fisk expressed outrage at the semantics of language that occurs within much of the reporting in the Middle East. "In the American press the occupied Palestinian territories become the disputed territories, a colony becomes a settlement or a neighborhood or an outpost. Here semantically, we are constantly degrading the reasons for Palestinian anger. Over and over again the wall becomes a fence. Like the Berlin fence-- had it been built by the Israelis, that's what it would have been called. Then for anyone who doesn't know the real semantics of this conflict, the Palestinians are generically violent. I mean who would ever protest over a garden fence or a neighborhood? The purpose of this kind of journalism is to diminish the real reasons behind the Middle East conflict."
Fisk went on to explain why he thinks the manipulation of language in reporting skews the truth. "We have another phrase we are introducing now. Have you noticed how these extraordinary creatures keep popping up in reports from Baghdad? 'Men in police uniform' took part in the kidnapping. 'Men in police uniform' abducted Margaret Hassan. 'Men in army uniform' besieged police stations," Fisk said, somewhat exasperated.
"Now do the reporters writing this garbage actually think there is a warehouse in Fallujah with eight thousand made to measure police uniforms for insurgents?" Fisk asked, then answered. "Of course there aren't, they are the policemen."
Fisk's main criticism was reserved for television coverage of the conflict. "Television connives at war because it will not show you the reality. If an Iraqi is lucky enough to die in a romantic position he will get on the air," Fisk said. He then added, "But if he doesn’t have a head on or if he is like most of the victims, torn to bits, you will not see him."
Fisk talked of his television colleague’s pictures being routinely censored by producers and editors back home. "I've heard them say this down the line, 'It's pornographic to show these pictures. We've got people at breakfast time; they will be puking over their cornflakes... We can't show this.' My favorite one is 'We've got to respect the dead.' We can kill them as much as we want, but once they’re dead we’ve got to respect them, right? And so you will be shielded from this war. You will be shielded from this reality."
Fisk believes having journalists holed up in the green zone suits the military forces in Iraq. "The Americans, and to a lesser extent the British, like it this way. They do not want us moving around. They do not want us going to the mortuaries and counting the dead."
Fisk told of an experience he had when visiting a Baghdad mortuary in August 2005. "The mortuary officials, against the law of Iraq, which doesn't count for much at the moment, let me see the Ministry of Health computer that American and British officials have ordered the ministry not to allow Western journalists access to...which showed that in July alone last year 1,100 Iraqis had died by violence, just in Baghdad."
Fisk challenged the standard reporting conventions hammered into journalism student's heads around the world. "There's one that comes up from the journalism school system which is you've got to give equal time to both sides," explained Fisk. "To which I say well, if you were reporting the slave trade in the 18th century, would you give equal time to the slave ship captain? No. If you're covering the liberation of a Nazi camp, do you give equal time to the SS spokesman? No. When I covered a Palestinian suicide bombing of a restaurant in Israeli west Jerusalem in August 2001, did I give equal time to the Islamic jihad spokesman? No. When 1,700 Palestinians were slaughtered in the Palestinian refugee camps of Sabra and Shatila in 1982, did I give equal time to the Israeli spokesman, who of course was representing an army who watched the massacre as its Lebanese Phalangist allies carried it out? No. Journalists should be on the side of the victims," Fisk said.
He closed with a sober warning to viewers and readers closely following the Iraq war coverage. "We have a real disaster on our hands because the American project in Iraq is dead and don't believe anything anyone else tells you in any newspaper. It is a catastrophe and every reporter working in Iraq knows it, but they don't all tell you that," Fisk said, pausing. "And that is our shame."
John Pilger
John Pilger addressed the audience next by challenging the very idea that America and its allies are at war. "We are not at war. Instead, American and British troops are fighting insurrections in countries where our invasions have caused mayhem and grief...but you wouldn't know it. Where are the pictures of these atrocities?"
Pilger referred to the first wars he covered, Vietnam and Cambodia, and compared the role of journalists then to today. "The invasion of Vietnam was deliberate and calculated--as were policies and strategies that bordered on genocide and were designed to force millions of people to abandon their homes. Experimental weapons were used against civilians. All of this was rarely news. The unspoken task of the reporter in Vietnam, as it was in Korea, was to normalize the unthinkable. And that has not changed."
Pilger went on to explain his reaction to current reporting of events in Iraq. "The other day, on the third anniversary of the invasion, a BBC newsreader described the invasion as a 'miscalculation.' Not illegal. Not unprovoked. Not based on lies. But a miscalculation. Thus, the unthinkable is normalized. By concentrating on military pronouncements. By making it seem like it is a respectable war, you normalize what is the unthinkable. And the unthinkable is a war against civilians. It's a war that has claimed tens of thousands of people. There are estimates that put it well over 100,000. When journalists report it as a respectable geopolitical act and promote the idea that it was to bring democracy to this country, then they're normalizing the unthinkable."
Pilger turned his attention to the BBC. Generally accepted worldwide as a reputable and independent source of information, Pilger rejected this notion outright. "In Britain, where I live, the BBC, which promotes itself as a sort of nirvana of objectivity and impartiality and truth, has blood all over its corporate hands." Pilger cited a study conducted by the journalism school of the University College in Cardiff that found in the lead up to the war, 90 percent of the BBC's references to weapons of mass destruction suggested Saddam Hussein actually possessed them.
Pilger added, "We now know that the BBC and other British media were used by MI-6, the secret intelligence service. In what they called Operation Mass Appeal, MI-6 agents planted stories about Saddam"s weapons of mass destruction, such as weapons hidden in his palaces and in secret underground bunkers. All of these stories were fake. But that's not the point. The point is that the role of MI-6 was quite unnecessary because a systematic media self-censorship produced the same result."
To Pilger the most significant way journalists are used by government is in what he calls a "softening up process" before planned military action. "We soften them up by dehumanizing them. Currently journalists are softening up Iran, Syria, and Venezuela," Pilger said. "A few weeks ago Channel 4 News in Britain, regarded as a good liberal news service, carried a major item that might have been broadcast by the State Department. The reporter presented President Chavez of Venezuela as a cartoon character, a sinister buffoon whose folksy Latin way disguised a man, and I quote, 'in danger of joining a rogues gallery of dictators and despots--Washington's latest Latin nightmare.'
"Rumsfeld was allowed to call Chavez 'Hitler' unchallenged. According to the reporter, Venezuela under Chavez was helping Iran develop nuclear weapons. No evidence was given for this bullshit." He cited a recent report by the media watchdog FAIR, which found that 95 percent of the 100 media commentaries surveyed expressed hostility to Chavez, with terms such as "dictator," "strongman," and "demagogue" regularly used in publications such as the Los Angeles Times and the Wall Street Journal. "The softening-up of Venezuela is well advanced in the United States. So that if or when the Bush administration launches Operation Bilbao, a contingent plan to overthrow the democratic government of Venezuela, who will care? We will have only the media version, another lousy demagogue got what was coming to him. A triumph of censorship by omission and by journalism," he concluded.
Seymour Hersh
The last speaker, Seymour Hersh, had just published his report on the Bush administration's secret plans for an attack on Iran, which he spoke about. "Here we've got a situation, which is really unique in our history. This is a president who is completely inured to the press. It doesn't matter what we write or say. He has got his own vision, whether he's talking to God or doing things on behalf of what his father didn't do or whatever it is. He has his own messianic view of what to do and he's not done," warned Hersh.
The moderator questioned Hersh about his use of anonymous sources and the possibility that his Iran story was from a government plant. "It's an appropriate question," he remarked.
"People would say are you part of the process, trying to put pressure on the Iranians by using psychological warfare and planting the story? I really wish they had that kind of cunning...that they would think in a Kissingerian way," he laughed. "But the fact is with George Bush, it's been very consistent. What you see is what you get."
"It was not a plant," Hersh explained. "This [report] came from people willing to take bullets for us... willing to put their lives on the line, who understand combat and who are scared to death about this guy in the White House." Hersh went on to warn the audience about what he thought would happen with the Bush administration and Iran; "Folks, don't bet against it because he's probably going to do it; because somebody up there is telling him this is the right thing to do."
Hersh considered the damning words of his colleagues. "Yes, it's important to beat up on us. As usual we deserve it. As usual we failed you totally," Hersh remarked wearily. "But above and beyond all that, folks, by my count there are something like 1,011 days left in the reign of King George the Lesser and that is the bad news. But there is good news. And the good news is that tomorrow when we wake up there will be one less day."
To a large round of applause, the afternoon ended. I asked Pilger his final thoughts. He paused and then replied, "Journalists, like politicians, like anybody really, should be called to account for the consequences of their actions. Journalists have played a critical role in sustaining wars. Starting them and sustaining them. And we have to face that discussion. There's nothing wrong with journalism, it's a wonderful privilege, it's a craft actually, and I'm very proud to be a journalist. But it's the way it's practiced. It's as if it has been hijacked by corporatism and we should take it back."
Sophie McNeill is a freelance video journalist whose work regularly appears on Australia’s SBS Television “Dateline” program. She lives in New York.
For the Bush administration to use the memory of a person who stood up to government propaganda is ironic to say the least. Secretary Rice told the assembled journalists that "without a free press to report on the activities of government, to ask questions of officials, to be a place where citizens can express themselves, democracy simply couldn't work."
One week earlier in New York City, Columbia University hosted a panel on the state of the world's media that would have been more in Murrow's style than the State Department-run symposium. Reporter and filmmaker John Pilger, British Middle East correspondent for the Independent Robert Fisk, freelance reporter Charlie Glass, and investigative journalist for the New Yorker Seymour Hersh appeared together at this April 14 event.
Before the afternoon panel began, I met up with John Pilger at his hotel. He'd just flown in from London and was only in New York for the panel before flying to Caracas, Venezuela the next day. A journalist for over 30 years, Pilger has reported from Vietnam, Cambodia, East Timor, Palestine, and Iraq--to name a few of the countries to which his investigative reporting and filmmaking had taken him.
Pilger told me that he'd never been as concerned about the state of the media as he was today. "I think there’s a lot of reasons to be very concerned about the information or the lack of information that we get. There's never been such an interest, more than an interest, almost an obsession, in controlling what journalists have to say."
Despite the fact that the war in Iraq is reported daily in most U.S. newspapers and networks around the world, Pilger didn't think the world's press accurately conveyed the reality of life for Iraqi civilians. "We get the illusion that we are seeing what might be happening in Iraq. But what we're getting is a massive censorship by omission; so much is being left out," he said. "We have a situation in Iraq where well over 100,000 civilians have been killed and we have virtually no pictures. The control of that by the Pentagon has been quite brilliant. And as a result we have no idea of the extent of civilians suffering in that country."
I asked Pilger what the untold story of Iraq was that's just not getting through. "Well, the untold story of Iraq should be obvious," Pilger said. "But it never is. The untold story of Vietnam was that it was an invasion and that huge numbers of civilians were killed. And in effect it was a war against civilians and that was never told and that's exactly true of Iraq."
With the majority of the world's press holed up behind 4.5 miles of concrete barrier in the green zone, it seems impossible for the standard of reporting to improve anytime in the near future. I asked Pilger if he blamed journalists for not wanting to put their lives at risk? "No, I can’t," he said. "But I don’t see the point of being in the green zone. I don't see the point of wearing a flak jacket and standing in a hotel in a fortress guarded by an invader.
"But there have been journalists--and others--who have actually gone with the insurgents; who have reported about them. One of them, for instance, is a young woman named Jo Wilding, a British human rights worker. She was in Fallujah all through that first attack in 2004. Jo Wilding's dispatches were some of the most extraordinary I've read, but they were never published anywhere."
Pilger said the mainstream press needs to get over its hang up of "our man in Baghdad" and prioritize whatever information can be obtained by whoever is brave enough or has the best contacts. "There are sources of information for what is happening inside Iraq. Most of them are on the web. I think those who give a damn in the mainstream really have to look at those sources and surrender their prejudice about them and say we need that reporter's work because he or she has told us something we can't possibly get ourselves. And I think that's the only way we will really serve the public."
We had talked too long and had to quickly jump in a cab to make it to the panel on time. The hall was packed with university students, professors, and the public.
Charlie Glass
The event quickly got underway with Charlie Glass as the first speaker. A former ABC America correspondent in the Middle East, Glass drew laughs from the crowd when comparing his experience to the other panelists. "When I began journalism I approached it in the way a lot of young naive people do, in that it was a vocation, a higher calling to tell the truth. My three colleagues up here have managed to do that throughout their careers. I tried very hard to do that throughout my career...but I worked for an American network. It's not easy," joked Glass.
Glass spoke about the censorship he had encountered as an American TV reporter covering the Middle East, referring to a story he filed during the Israeli invasion of Lebanon in 1982. There had been rumors of Israeli Shin Bath death squads murdering Lebanese civilians in the South and Glass and his crew had managed to film the evidence behind these killings. "We nailed this story. We folded one of the death squads. We got to the palace where they had assassinated a man half an hour after he had been killed. We filmed it. We filmed the eyewitness. We filmed UN soldiers, who had seen the same things, discussing it," recalled Glass.
"ABC news didn’t broadcast it. But they won't tell you they're not going to broadcast it because they're afraid of losing advertising. They won't tell you they won't broadcast it because they're afraid of the public reaction. They tell you they just didn't have room that night or the next night or the next night. And that's just the way it is. That is why very few people in this country have any idea what’s going on in the Middle East."
Glass believes this kind of censorship has led to a chasm of misunderstanding within the U.S. public. "You don't understand what's been going on in Iraq because you've been lied to again. Just like you were in Vietnam. Just like you were in Lebanon and just like you were in the West Bank and Gaza," he said.
"Nobody has a clue why things went wrong in Iraq. Well, I’ll tell you why. They were always going to go wrong in Iraq. It wasn't because Bremer screwed up. It wasn't because the U.S. pilfered the Iraqi treasury, which is true. It wasn't because some soldiers misbehaved and shot some people in cars. It was because it could never go right in Iraq," Glass insisted. "The U.S. was not trusted by any Iraqi because the U.S. history in Iraq was so reprehensible--from the betrayal of the Kurds in 1975 when Henry Kissinger sold them out and they were massacred in the tens of thousands by Saddam, from the time they aided Saddam during the Iran/Iraq war, from the time they betrayed the Kurdish and Shia rebellions in 1991, from the sanctions regime that followed.
"Who would trust a power to liberate them who had already behaved like that? It isn't a question of what happened after; it’s a question of what happened before. We had an obligation to tell what happened before and we didn't," Glass said, before pausing to take a moment. "I've lost my vocation. I actually don't really like this profession anymore," Glass said regrettably.
Robert Fisk
Next to speak was Middle East correspondent Robert Fisk, arguably the world's most experienced Western reporter in the region. Fisk pulled out a copy of the New York Times and spread it out on the lectern. "This is from this morning's paper: Al-Qaeda's man in Iraq gets encouragement from HQ," Fisk read aloud. "An interior minister official said, officials said, the American military said, the Iraqi government said, some American officials here observed, and some military officials have said, two American intelligence officials said, one Pakistani official said, and I've only got to column two," Fisk exclaimed. "I've always believed that your major newspaper should be called 'American Officials Say.' Then you can just scrap all the reporting and have the Pentagon talking directly."
Fisk expressed outrage at the semantics of language that occurs within much of the reporting in the Middle East. "In the American press the occupied Palestinian territories become the disputed territories, a colony becomes a settlement or a neighborhood or an outpost. Here semantically, we are constantly degrading the reasons for Palestinian anger. Over and over again the wall becomes a fence. Like the Berlin fence-- had it been built by the Israelis, that's what it would have been called. Then for anyone who doesn't know the real semantics of this conflict, the Palestinians are generically violent. I mean who would ever protest over a garden fence or a neighborhood? The purpose of this kind of journalism is to diminish the real reasons behind the Middle East conflict."
Fisk went on to explain why he thinks the manipulation of language in reporting skews the truth. "We have another phrase we are introducing now. Have you noticed how these extraordinary creatures keep popping up in reports from Baghdad? 'Men in police uniform' took part in the kidnapping. 'Men in police uniform' abducted Margaret Hassan. 'Men in army uniform' besieged police stations," Fisk said, somewhat exasperated.
"Now do the reporters writing this garbage actually think there is a warehouse in Fallujah with eight thousand made to measure police uniforms for insurgents?" Fisk asked, then answered. "Of course there aren't, they are the policemen."
Fisk's main criticism was reserved for television coverage of the conflict. "Television connives at war because it will not show you the reality. If an Iraqi is lucky enough to die in a romantic position he will get on the air," Fisk said. He then added, "But if he doesn’t have a head on or if he is like most of the victims, torn to bits, you will not see him."
Fisk talked of his television colleague’s pictures being routinely censored by producers and editors back home. "I've heard them say this down the line, 'It's pornographic to show these pictures. We've got people at breakfast time; they will be puking over their cornflakes... We can't show this.' My favorite one is 'We've got to respect the dead.' We can kill them as much as we want, but once they’re dead we’ve got to respect them, right? And so you will be shielded from this war. You will be shielded from this reality."
Fisk believes having journalists holed up in the green zone suits the military forces in Iraq. "The Americans, and to a lesser extent the British, like it this way. They do not want us moving around. They do not want us going to the mortuaries and counting the dead."
Fisk told of an experience he had when visiting a Baghdad mortuary in August 2005. "The mortuary officials, against the law of Iraq, which doesn't count for much at the moment, let me see the Ministry of Health computer that American and British officials have ordered the ministry not to allow Western journalists access to...which showed that in July alone last year 1,100 Iraqis had died by violence, just in Baghdad."
Fisk challenged the standard reporting conventions hammered into journalism student's heads around the world. "There's one that comes up from the journalism school system which is you've got to give equal time to both sides," explained Fisk. "To which I say well, if you were reporting the slave trade in the 18th century, would you give equal time to the slave ship captain? No. If you're covering the liberation of a Nazi camp, do you give equal time to the SS spokesman? No. When I covered a Palestinian suicide bombing of a restaurant in Israeli west Jerusalem in August 2001, did I give equal time to the Islamic jihad spokesman? No. When 1,700 Palestinians were slaughtered in the Palestinian refugee camps of Sabra and Shatila in 1982, did I give equal time to the Israeli spokesman, who of course was representing an army who watched the massacre as its Lebanese Phalangist allies carried it out? No. Journalists should be on the side of the victims," Fisk said.
He closed with a sober warning to viewers and readers closely following the Iraq war coverage. "We have a real disaster on our hands because the American project in Iraq is dead and don't believe anything anyone else tells you in any newspaper. It is a catastrophe and every reporter working in Iraq knows it, but they don't all tell you that," Fisk said, pausing. "And that is our shame."
John Pilger
John Pilger addressed the audience next by challenging the very idea that America and its allies are at war. "We are not at war. Instead, American and British troops are fighting insurrections in countries where our invasions have caused mayhem and grief...but you wouldn't know it. Where are the pictures of these atrocities?"
Pilger referred to the first wars he covered, Vietnam and Cambodia, and compared the role of journalists then to today. "The invasion of Vietnam was deliberate and calculated--as were policies and strategies that bordered on genocide and were designed to force millions of people to abandon their homes. Experimental weapons were used against civilians. All of this was rarely news. The unspoken task of the reporter in Vietnam, as it was in Korea, was to normalize the unthinkable. And that has not changed."
Pilger went on to explain his reaction to current reporting of events in Iraq. "The other day, on the third anniversary of the invasion, a BBC newsreader described the invasion as a 'miscalculation.' Not illegal. Not unprovoked. Not based on lies. But a miscalculation. Thus, the unthinkable is normalized. By concentrating on military pronouncements. By making it seem like it is a respectable war, you normalize what is the unthinkable. And the unthinkable is a war against civilians. It's a war that has claimed tens of thousands of people. There are estimates that put it well over 100,000. When journalists report it as a respectable geopolitical act and promote the idea that it was to bring democracy to this country, then they're normalizing the unthinkable."
Pilger turned his attention to the BBC. Generally accepted worldwide as a reputable and independent source of information, Pilger rejected this notion outright. "In Britain, where I live, the BBC, which promotes itself as a sort of nirvana of objectivity and impartiality and truth, has blood all over its corporate hands." Pilger cited a study conducted by the journalism school of the University College in Cardiff that found in the lead up to the war, 90 percent of the BBC's references to weapons of mass destruction suggested Saddam Hussein actually possessed them.
Pilger added, "We now know that the BBC and other British media were used by MI-6, the secret intelligence service. In what they called Operation Mass Appeal, MI-6 agents planted stories about Saddam"s weapons of mass destruction, such as weapons hidden in his palaces and in secret underground bunkers. All of these stories were fake. But that's not the point. The point is that the role of MI-6 was quite unnecessary because a systematic media self-censorship produced the same result."
To Pilger the most significant way journalists are used by government is in what he calls a "softening up process" before planned military action. "We soften them up by dehumanizing them. Currently journalists are softening up Iran, Syria, and Venezuela," Pilger said. "A few weeks ago Channel 4 News in Britain, regarded as a good liberal news service, carried a major item that might have been broadcast by the State Department. The reporter presented President Chavez of Venezuela as a cartoon character, a sinister buffoon whose folksy Latin way disguised a man, and I quote, 'in danger of joining a rogues gallery of dictators and despots--Washington's latest Latin nightmare.'
"Rumsfeld was allowed to call Chavez 'Hitler' unchallenged. According to the reporter, Venezuela under Chavez was helping Iran develop nuclear weapons. No evidence was given for this bullshit." He cited a recent report by the media watchdog FAIR, which found that 95 percent of the 100 media commentaries surveyed expressed hostility to Chavez, with terms such as "dictator," "strongman," and "demagogue" regularly used in publications such as the Los Angeles Times and the Wall Street Journal. "The softening-up of Venezuela is well advanced in the United States. So that if or when the Bush administration launches Operation Bilbao, a contingent plan to overthrow the democratic government of Venezuela, who will care? We will have only the media version, another lousy demagogue got what was coming to him. A triumph of censorship by omission and by journalism," he concluded.
Seymour Hersh
The last speaker, Seymour Hersh, had just published his report on the Bush administration's secret plans for an attack on Iran, which he spoke about. "Here we've got a situation, which is really unique in our history. This is a president who is completely inured to the press. It doesn't matter what we write or say. He has got his own vision, whether he's talking to God or doing things on behalf of what his father didn't do or whatever it is. He has his own messianic view of what to do and he's not done," warned Hersh.
The moderator questioned Hersh about his use of anonymous sources and the possibility that his Iran story was from a government plant. "It's an appropriate question," he remarked.
"People would say are you part of the process, trying to put pressure on the Iranians by using psychological warfare and planting the story? I really wish they had that kind of cunning...that they would think in a Kissingerian way," he laughed. "But the fact is with George Bush, it's been very consistent. What you see is what you get."
"It was not a plant," Hersh explained. "This [report] came from people willing to take bullets for us... willing to put their lives on the line, who understand combat and who are scared to death about this guy in the White House." Hersh went on to warn the audience about what he thought would happen with the Bush administration and Iran; "Folks, don't bet against it because he's probably going to do it; because somebody up there is telling him this is the right thing to do."
Hersh considered the damning words of his colleagues. "Yes, it's important to beat up on us. As usual we deserve it. As usual we failed you totally," Hersh remarked wearily. "But above and beyond all that, folks, by my count there are something like 1,011 days left in the reign of King George the Lesser and that is the bad news. But there is good news. And the good news is that tomorrow when we wake up there will be one less day."
To a large round of applause, the afternoon ended. I asked Pilger his final thoughts. He paused and then replied, "Journalists, like politicians, like anybody really, should be called to account for the consequences of their actions. Journalists have played a critical role in sustaining wars. Starting them and sustaining them. And we have to face that discussion. There's nothing wrong with journalism, it's a wonderful privilege, it's a craft actually, and I'm very proud to be a journalist. But it's the way it's practiced. It's as if it has been hijacked by corporatism and we should take it back."
Sophie McNeill is a freelance video journalist whose work regularly appears on Australia’s SBS Television “Dateline” program. She lives in New York.
Haditha and the Farrago of Lies - War Crimes Start at the Top By BRIAN CLOUGHLEY
"[W]e must understand that we're in a global war against a totalitarian group of people who will kill innocent life, there or here, in order to achieve an objective.""The ultimate cause of why civilians were injured and killed is because the Taliban knowingly, willfully chose to occupy homes of these people."
George W Bush (At the National Restaurant Convention in Chicago), May 22, 2006.
US spokesman in Afghanistan, Colonel Collins, May 24, 2006.
"A military investigation into the deaths of two dozen Iraqis last November is expected to find that a small number of marines in western Iraq carried out extensive, unprovoked killings of civilians . . ."
New York Times, May 25, 2006.
The United States military conducted air strikes in Afghanistan on May 21-22 that killed at least 16 civilians. Women and children were ripped to pieces by a hail of bullets and bombs. Over a dozen other civilians were injured and the US military's justification for the slaughter is that some ("between 20 and 80") Afghan fighters against the US occupation were killed, too, in the yippee shoot. US forces blasted an Afghan village and then claimed they did everything that could be done to "prevent killing civilians".
Hogwash.
There was not the slightest effort made by the US military in Afghanistan to "prevent killing civilians" in that air blitz. They first announced that the aim of their operation was "to detain individuals suspected of terrorist and anti-Afghanistan activities." Just how do you "DETAIN individuals suspected of terrorism" by having airplanes spray bullets at them? But then, as pointed out at http://lefti.blogspot.com/ (always worth a visit), the robo-spokesmen dropped the word "suspected" and announced that "These individuals were active members of the Taliban network and have conducted attacks against coalition and Afghan forces as well as civilians".
How could the US Command in Afghanistan know these "individuals" were "active members of the Taliban network"? Did they carry identity cards? Was any American or Afghan government official present at their burial to verify their identity? Can the US Command give an example of an attack by these people on civilians? Why did the military at first say they were suspects then declare later they were active Taliban?
None of the conventional media ever ask such questions about massacres in Afghanistan or Iraq. Tame newspapers like the New York Times carry things like "[it] is expected to find that a small number of marines in western Iraq carried out extensive, unprovoked killings of civilians" on November 19, 2005. Note the words "small number", as if this made the murders not quite so horrible. We're back to the "few bad apples" rubbish spouted by Rumsfeld and his pathetic hand-puppet generals about US troops' torture and murders in prisons, and the killing of unarmed and innocent civilians.
Marines are said to have murdered 24 or more civilians in the "incident" (what a nice word) in Haditha last November. If they did, they were, in the words of Bush, "a totalitarian group of people who will kill innocent life, there or here, in order to achieve an objective." And the objective of this group of marines was slaughter for revenge. A marine had died in a roadside bombing, so there was a killing spree. After firm denials that deliberate murder of civilians had taken place, evidence was produced (not, of course, by the US military), that a major war crime had been committed.
The LA Times, which seems to be better than most newspapers at providing hard facts, reported on May 26 that "In its initial statement to the media, the Marine Corps said the Iraqi civilians were killed either by an insurgent bomb or by crossfire between Marines and insurgents. But after Time Magazine obtained pictures showing dead women and children and quoted Iraqis who said the attack was unprovoked, the Marine Corps backtracked on its explanation and called for an investigation." One military spokeswoman had said that guerrillas "placed non-combatants in the line of fire as the Marines responded to defend themselves", which was an outrageous concoction of lies, and in a bizarre attempt to deflect journalistic investigation Marine Captain Jeffrey S Poole -- he who retailed the original fabrication -- emailed the Time reporter to tell him his story was based on al-Qaeda propaganda.
The American armed forces have descended to new and horrible depths of dishonesty. The instant automatic response to an accusation of evil-doing by its members is strong denial. There is no consideration given to saying something honest like "We don't know what happened and we'll have a good look at it." The plain fact is that nobody can trust the US military to tell the truth, ever again, until there is eradication of the culture of deceit. There has to be a cleansing of the stables, a weeding-out of those who are devoted to the ethos of killing for the sake of killing and lying for the sake of lying.
Do you remember the story of Pat Tillman? The US Army, from top to bottom, told or ignored deliberate lies about the circumstances of his death in Afghanistan. Pat was a great man and he served his country well. But his memory was dishonored by vile people who used his death for propaganda.
Pat Tillman, may he rest in peace, was killed by soldiers of his own side in an episode of gross military incompetence. But the US Army didn't only try to cover up the whole squalid shambles : it told lies to make the US public believe that a soldier who was shot by his own comrades had died as a result of enemy action, and compounded the insult by awarding him a posthumous medal. Generals of the US Army knew the truth about the affair, but decided that the army should have a well-publicized hero and told lies to put Pat Tillman in the headlines--and they succeeded because Time magazine featured him on its cover. Mere words cannot describe the filth who thought up this deception. Their action didn't only dishonor all concerned : it showed the world that the Decider-in-Chief, George Bush, had sent his amoral message down the chain of command. And that message was that lies can be endorsed by his Administration, providing the story doesn't eventually fall apart.
Of course there are many in the US Army and Marines who behave honorably, and they are probably in the majority. (And let it be placed on record that the US Marine medics in earthquake-devastated Kashmir were efficient and enormously popular. I've just returned from a visit to Pakistan and was greatly impressed by tales of their dedication.) But please reflect on this military truth: When uniformed people, supposedly under military discipline, behave like berserk demons from hell, killing the innocent and torturing at will, the final responsibility lies AT THE TOP.
There used to be a saying that there were no bad soldiers, only bad officers. This is a simplistic way of looking at things, because bad soldiers can exist even when officers are good. But when bad soldiers behave in a fashion that would have the Nazi SS nod in approving admiration at their mindless ferocity, than the blame rests squarely with those in authority : their leaders, the officers. If they didn't know what was going on (be that murder, torture or lying for propaganda), they are incompetent nitwits. If they knew what was going on and ignored it they are weak and pathetic cretins. If they approved evil or attempted a cover-up, then they are depraved monsters who should be prosecuted with the full force of law.
Your call.
If you wonder about the military's commitment to morality, please reflect on this exchange between General Michael V Hayden, the new CIA Director, and Senator Dianne Feinstein (D-CA):
Senator Feinstein: Is waterboarding an acceptable interrogation technique? [Waterboarding is a torture designed to make victims believe they will die by drowning if they do not provide correct answers to their interrogators.]
General Hayden: Let me defer that to closed session, and I would be happy to discuss it in some detail.
The general wants to DISCUSS torture? The only possible answer by a human being to the senator's question is a flat NO, followed by a withering observation to the effect that "I am surprised you should ask such a question of a United States military officer". Any answer other than a flat 'No' means that Hayden is not prepared to state he does not approve of torture by semi-drowning.
That's the way the US military thinks, these days, and Hayden is the Bush appointee who will have ultimate responsibility for the CIA's interrogation chambers in secret jails around the world. He will be responsible for "rendition" of helpless non-persons to these prisons where there is no accountability for waterboarding or who knows what other hideous torment. (There are people who actually make a living, as US government employees, by thinking up new tortures. Just think about that.)
From the fabrication of pro-war propaganda, such as the farrago of lies about the "heroism" of poor Private Jessica Lynch, to the war crimes of killing women and children, the US military seeks new depths to conquer. The Marines who murdered Iraqis last November might have been motivated by their president's "war against terror", but they showed their support in a weird way. Consider this statement from a little Iraqi girl:
"I couldn't see their faces very well - only their guns sticking into the doorway. I watched them shoot my grandfather, first in the chest and then in the head. Then they killed my granny."
There is an inquiry being conducted into the murders, but we should remember another investigation about a Marine atrocity. In November 2004 a Marine murdered an unarmed helpless Iraqi who was lying defenseless and comatose on the floor of a building. The murder was filmed by an NBC cameraman who was later vilified for being anti-American. The Marine was not charged with any offence.
It should be borne in mind that no Iraqi government agency or official has been permitted to join in the investigation into the deaths of their citizens. So much for Bush "democracy" and his support for the "independent" Iraqi government. Remember his words on May 27?: "The formation of a democratic government in Iraq marks a victory for the cause of freedom in the Middle East." What democratic government in the world has to bow the knee to an invader whose soldiers kill its people? What democratic government in the world is prevented by an occupying military power from independently investigating the murder of its citizens?
Not one of the war crimes by US forces in Iraq and Afghanistan has resulted in prosecution of those who are ultimately responsible. Those who personally killed or tortured "innocent life", as Bush has it, received token tiny sentences in prisons in which, be assured, they will be treated as honored warriors. (One killer of an innocent civilian in a US military prison in Afghanistan was fined six thousand dollars.) Their superior officers receive presidential plaudits, promotion, and even more medals on their chests for their success in buck-passing--downwards. The announcement by Bush on May 31 that he is "troubled" by reports of atrocities in Iraq and that "If in fact the laws were broken there will be punishment", can be taken with a very large spoonful of salt.
Congressman John Murtha summed it up by saying "It goes right up the chain of command. Who ordered the cover-up? Who said, 'we're not going to publicize this thing, we're not even going to investigate it'?"
War crimes have been committed with near-impunity, and there is an important side effect : most citizens of the countries in which the US military massacred civilians will detest America and Americans for ever. The Taliban in Afghanistan have been given an enormous boost by US atrocities. This is part of the Bush legacy. The next administration is going to have a hard job to restore world confidence in American justice, and it may never succeed. But at least it could make a start by getting rid of officers who want to "discuss" torture rather than declaring it to be evil and those whose first reaction to a war crime is to try to hush it up.
Brian Cloughley writes on military and political affairs. He can be reached through his website www.briancloughley.com
The Meaning of Haditha - Murderous depravity and empire-building go hand-in-hand
The Haditha massacre, as it will doubtless be known, tells us something about this war we are fighting, and something about ourselves as Americans – or, rather, as creatures who have become a little less American in the post-9/11 era. What that something amounts to, according to your view of the war and of U.S. foreign policy, varies, but not that much. Both ostensible critics of the war and those neoconservatives who still see it as a noble cause derailed by defeatists and lack of will assume the essential goodness of American troops, both as individuals and as a unit. It's only a few "bad apples" who are the problem. This view was given voice in a National Review editorial decrying the designation of war critic John Murtha as a recipient of the "Profiles in Courage" award handed out by the JFK Library. In a display of breathtaking nerviness, the weenies over at NR – who have never gotten closer to a U.S military facility than driving past one – attacked war hero Murtha for supposedly dissing the troops:
"Even if the allegations against the Marines are true, Murtha's rhetoric is imbalanced: He declines to emphasize that the vast majority of soldiers perform their duties honorably and that those who break the rules are severely punished, choosing instead to cite the actions of a few sadists as though they were representative of the military."
Surely this could be said about most armies in the history of human warfare: the overwhelming majority do not commit war crimes. They're too busy just trying to stay alive. But what this has to do with the cold hard fact that these U.S. Marines did commit a number of especially horrible atrocities is not at all clear. Aside from that, they have Murtha all wrong. He is full of excuses for American soldiers who murder children as young as 1 year old:
"They were so stressed out, they went into houses and killed children, women and children. 24 people they killed. Now this is the kind of stress they are under. Listen, I don't excuse it, but I understand what's happening and the responsibility goes right to the top. This is something that should not have happened, that should have been investigated, they've already relieved three commanding officers … but this is the kind of stuff … stress is going to cause these kind of things. That's why I'm so upset about it."
"Stress," my a**. We are not talking about National Guard units, here: these are U.S. Marines, highly-trained killing machines who know the rules of war, know the difference between a woman with a baby in her arms and a group of insurgents, and know, furthermore, that the war they are fighting is supposed to be against terrorism. Would they succumb to "stress" like some housewife who's run out of vacuum-cleaner bags, go ballistic, and slaughter 24 innocents, including women and very young children, if they didn't think they could get away with it? In short, would they have done it if it wasn't policy – directed, encouraged, and condoned by their commanders?
Hell, no.
Yes, Murtha is right: those Marines aren't going to take the fall all by themselves, the responsibility does go right to the top – but they, as individuals, are not absolved. They pulled the trigger, they slaughtered children, fer chrissake, executed them in cold blood. So they're responsible – right? If they were Iraqis, there wouldn't be any question about that: we wouldn't be talking about "stress," now would we? Does the fact that they're Americans somehow ameliorate their crimes? I don't think so.
Last year, I wrote about the "El Salvador option" – the emerging strategy of this administration in fighting a losing war, which amounts to throwing off all constraints and simply terrorizing the Iraqi people into cowed submission. We are now seeing the results of this policy of desperation in practice. Haditha is not just an "isolated incident," but evidence of a new strategic orientation by the U.S. military – a scorched-earth policy designed to stave off the humiliating prospect of impending defeat.
Further evidence of this new orientation is the revelation of yet another massacre, this time in the village of Abu Sifa, about 60 miles north of Baghdad. Of course, it isn't a revelation to readers of Antiwar.com and this column, where we covered it in detail back in March. The Times of London reported it, most of the American media ignored it, and the news dropped like a stone, clear out of sight and out of mind – except that, as in the case of Haditha, a videotape has come out that vividly documents American atrocities.
A pattern emerges: Haditha, Abu Sifa, Abu Ghraib, and all the others now bound to come out in horrifying detail. These place names will become the new slogans of the Iraqi insurgency, which will be fueled as never before – and perhaps immeasurably strengthened by rising Shi'ite anger. As we said in the beginning – nay, before the beginning – the occupation of Iraq will soon take on all the familiar earmarks of the Israeli occupation of Palestine. Both Iraqis and Americans will be locked in a deadly embrace of indignities that will soon escalate into everyday atrocities. The Iraqis, like the Palestinians, will become captives in their own land, and their jailers will get progressively more abusive and cruel as a matter of sheer necessity. Iraq is the occupied territories writ large, and we are well on our way to becoming as hardened, as self-exculpatory, and as ruthless as our Israeli allies.
"A few sadists" – or a nation of sadists? That's what this whole question boils down to: have we become so corrupted by ambition and blinded by self-righteousness that we have spawned an army of baby-killers? And are we going to make weak excuses for them – by crying over the amount of "stress" the poor dears have to endure – or will we face the truth, about ourselves as well as them?
The ugly truth is that we have been corrupted by dreams of empire: our foreign and military policy of "preemption" is the doctrine of a swaggering bully. To claim preeminence on every continent, to strut and preen on the world stage and demand applause at gunpoint, this is evidence of a collective mania, a severe psychological affliction, and, I might add, a mortal sin – the sin of hubris.
We imagine that we are, like Nietzsche's "overman," beyond good and evil: acts that would be judged harshly if done by others become, in ourselves, evidence of unsurpassed virtue. Yes, our soldiers commit atrocities – but they are being investigated and prosecuted, aren't they? Well, that remains to be seen, but, in any event, what this argument misses is that our policy of untrammeled aggression requires terroristic tactics. If we don't have the stomach to kill women and children, then we had better turn back now. Because there is no nice way to be a global hegemon. We either give up the role, or else resign ourselves to many more Hadithas.
Back in October 2002, in a speech at Missouri's Washington University, as the likelihood of an American invasion of Iraq grew into a certainty, I warned about the "corruption of empire" that would inevitably infect every aspect of our culture. I spoke of "what is new – or so old that it seems new – about Gulf War II," and said:
"The mask has been dropped, and now we see the face of the monster revealed in all its shameless, leering ugliness. It's as if Dorian Gray has hauled his portrait out of the locked attic and hung it over his mantelpiece."
If we can look into the monster's face unflinchingly and recognize it as our own, then we have the wherewithal to implement our imperial foreign policy. If not – if we retain enough of our humanity to recoil in horror – then perhaps we ought to find ourselves another line of work, and get out of the empire-building business for good.
"Even if the allegations against the Marines are true, Murtha's rhetoric is imbalanced: He declines to emphasize that the vast majority of soldiers perform their duties honorably and that those who break the rules are severely punished, choosing instead to cite the actions of a few sadists as though they were representative of the military."
Surely this could be said about most armies in the history of human warfare: the overwhelming majority do not commit war crimes. They're too busy just trying to stay alive. But what this has to do with the cold hard fact that these U.S. Marines did commit a number of especially horrible atrocities is not at all clear. Aside from that, they have Murtha all wrong. He is full of excuses for American soldiers who murder children as young as 1 year old:
"They were so stressed out, they went into houses and killed children, women and children. 24 people they killed. Now this is the kind of stress they are under. Listen, I don't excuse it, but I understand what's happening and the responsibility goes right to the top. This is something that should not have happened, that should have been investigated, they've already relieved three commanding officers … but this is the kind of stuff … stress is going to cause these kind of things. That's why I'm so upset about it."
"Stress," my a**. We are not talking about National Guard units, here: these are U.S. Marines, highly-trained killing machines who know the rules of war, know the difference between a woman with a baby in her arms and a group of insurgents, and know, furthermore, that the war they are fighting is supposed to be against terrorism. Would they succumb to "stress" like some housewife who's run out of vacuum-cleaner bags, go ballistic, and slaughter 24 innocents, including women and very young children, if they didn't think they could get away with it? In short, would they have done it if it wasn't policy – directed, encouraged, and condoned by their commanders?
Hell, no.
Yes, Murtha is right: those Marines aren't going to take the fall all by themselves, the responsibility does go right to the top – but they, as individuals, are not absolved. They pulled the trigger, they slaughtered children, fer chrissake, executed them in cold blood. So they're responsible – right? If they were Iraqis, there wouldn't be any question about that: we wouldn't be talking about "stress," now would we? Does the fact that they're Americans somehow ameliorate their crimes? I don't think so.
Last year, I wrote about the "El Salvador option" – the emerging strategy of this administration in fighting a losing war, which amounts to throwing off all constraints and simply terrorizing the Iraqi people into cowed submission. We are now seeing the results of this policy of desperation in practice. Haditha is not just an "isolated incident," but evidence of a new strategic orientation by the U.S. military – a scorched-earth policy designed to stave off the humiliating prospect of impending defeat.
Further evidence of this new orientation is the revelation of yet another massacre, this time in the village of Abu Sifa, about 60 miles north of Baghdad. Of course, it isn't a revelation to readers of Antiwar.com and this column, where we covered it in detail back in March. The Times of London reported it, most of the American media ignored it, and the news dropped like a stone, clear out of sight and out of mind – except that, as in the case of Haditha, a videotape has come out that vividly documents American atrocities.
A pattern emerges: Haditha, Abu Sifa, Abu Ghraib, and all the others now bound to come out in horrifying detail. These place names will become the new slogans of the Iraqi insurgency, which will be fueled as never before – and perhaps immeasurably strengthened by rising Shi'ite anger. As we said in the beginning – nay, before the beginning – the occupation of Iraq will soon take on all the familiar earmarks of the Israeli occupation of Palestine. Both Iraqis and Americans will be locked in a deadly embrace of indignities that will soon escalate into everyday atrocities. The Iraqis, like the Palestinians, will become captives in their own land, and their jailers will get progressively more abusive and cruel as a matter of sheer necessity. Iraq is the occupied territories writ large, and we are well on our way to becoming as hardened, as self-exculpatory, and as ruthless as our Israeli allies.
"A few sadists" – or a nation of sadists? That's what this whole question boils down to: have we become so corrupted by ambition and blinded by self-righteousness that we have spawned an army of baby-killers? And are we going to make weak excuses for them – by crying over the amount of "stress" the poor dears have to endure – or will we face the truth, about ourselves as well as them?
The ugly truth is that we have been corrupted by dreams of empire: our foreign and military policy of "preemption" is the doctrine of a swaggering bully. To claim preeminence on every continent, to strut and preen on the world stage and demand applause at gunpoint, this is evidence of a collective mania, a severe psychological affliction, and, I might add, a mortal sin – the sin of hubris.
We imagine that we are, like Nietzsche's "overman," beyond good and evil: acts that would be judged harshly if done by others become, in ourselves, evidence of unsurpassed virtue. Yes, our soldiers commit atrocities – but they are being investigated and prosecuted, aren't they? Well, that remains to be seen, but, in any event, what this argument misses is that our policy of untrammeled aggression requires terroristic tactics. If we don't have the stomach to kill women and children, then we had better turn back now. Because there is no nice way to be a global hegemon. We either give up the role, or else resign ourselves to many more Hadithas.
Back in October 2002, in a speech at Missouri's Washington University, as the likelihood of an American invasion of Iraq grew into a certainty, I warned about the "corruption of empire" that would inevitably infect every aspect of our culture. I spoke of "what is new – or so old that it seems new – about Gulf War II," and said:
"The mask has been dropped, and now we see the face of the monster revealed in all its shameless, leering ugliness. It's as if Dorian Gray has hauled his portrait out of the locked attic and hung it over his mantelpiece."
If we can look into the monster's face unflinchingly and recognize it as our own, then we have the wherewithal to implement our imperial foreign policy. If not – if we retain enough of our humanity to recoil in horror – then perhaps we ought to find ourselves another line of work, and get out of the empire-building business for good.
Harry Belafonte warns of accelerating Neo-Fascism South of the Border
Following U.S. Senator Hilary Clinton's Martin Luther King Day remarks about the House of Representatives being run like a "plantation," singer and activist Harry Belafonte compared the Department of Homeland Security south of the Border in the United States, to the Nazi Gestapo and called the U.S. President George W. Bush, a liar during a speech in New York in late-January 2006.
"We've come to this dark time in which the new Gestapo of Homeland Security lurks here, where citizens are having their rights suspended," Belafonte said in a speech to the annual meeting of the Arts Presenters Members Conference. "You can be arrested and not charged. You can be arrested and have no right to counsel."
"You can be arrested and not charged, you can be arrested and have no right to counsel," said Belafonte, who called U.S. President Bush "the greatest terrorist in the world" during a trip to Venezuela two weeks ago. Belafonte, 78, made that comment after a meeting with Venezuelan leader Hugo Chavez.
Belafonte acknowledged that the 9/11 terrorist attacks in 2001 demanded a response by the United States, but said the policies of the Bush administration were ill advised.
"Fascism is fascism. Terrorism is terrorism. Oppression is oppression," said Belafonte, who served in the U.S. Navy during World War II. He added that Bush rose to power "somewhat dubiously and ... then lies to the people of this nation [United States], misleads them, mis-instructs, and then sends off hundreds of thousands of our own boys and girls to a foreign land that has not aggressed against us."
The Harlem-born Belafonte, who was raised in Jamaica, said his activism was inspired by an impoverished mother "who imbued in me that we should never capitulate to oppression."
Belafonte's words, part of a 45 minute speech on the role of the arts in a politically changing world, received roaring standing ovations, as reported by the Associated Press.
Harry Belafonte's daughter Shari, used to live in Toronto; and also hosted a TVOntario programme.
"We've come to this dark time in which the new Gestapo of Homeland Security lurks here, where citizens are having their rights suspended," Belafonte said in a speech to the annual meeting of the Arts Presenters Members Conference. "You can be arrested and not charged. You can be arrested and have no right to counsel."
"You can be arrested and not charged, you can be arrested and have no right to counsel," said Belafonte, who called U.S. President Bush "the greatest terrorist in the world" during a trip to Venezuela two weeks ago. Belafonte, 78, made that comment after a meeting with Venezuelan leader Hugo Chavez.
Belafonte acknowledged that the 9/11 terrorist attacks in 2001 demanded a response by the United States, but said the policies of the Bush administration were ill advised.
"Fascism is fascism. Terrorism is terrorism. Oppression is oppression," said Belafonte, who served in the U.S. Navy during World War II. He added that Bush rose to power "somewhat dubiously and ... then lies to the people of this nation [United States], misleads them, mis-instructs, and then sends off hundreds of thousands of our own boys and girls to a foreign land that has not aggressed against us."
The Harlem-born Belafonte, who was raised in Jamaica, said his activism was inspired by an impoverished mother "who imbued in me that we should never capitulate to oppression."
Belafonte's words, part of a 45 minute speech on the role of the arts in a politically changing world, received roaring standing ovations, as reported by the Associated Press.
Harry Belafonte's daughter Shari, used to live in Toronto; and also hosted a TVOntario programme.
In Las Vegas a cowardly military assassin in an air conditioned trailer pulls the trigger. In Iraq a Predator fires its missile
An RAF unit based in the Nevada desert is conducting highly secret operations against Iraqi insurgents and Afghan guerrillas using unmanned, powerfully armed American Predator aircraft.
Opening 1115 Flight's doors to a news organisation for the first time, the unit commander, Sqn Ldr Andy Bird, told The Daily Telegraph that British crews had "engaged targets" six times and had inflicted casualties.
Many of the operational details are classified but RAF officers showed grainy video footage from one operation in which a Hellfire missile is seen striking a building used by an Iraqi sniper lying in wait for targets among coalition forces. The gunman was killed.
Another video showed the final moments of an Iraqi who was trying to set up a roadside bomb.
The 700 Predators, which are the size of a light aircraft, are based at airfields in faraway war zones but are piloted using satellite links from cabins at Nellis Air Force Base, on the outskirts of Las Vegas.
The aircraft, coated in bullet-proof kevlar material and nearly invisible to radar, has rapidly become one of the most valued weapons in modern warfare, giving commanders the ability to spy on an unsuspecting enemy and launch attacks on him.
It is viewed by admirers as a pin-up in the war on terrorism and has been used innumerable times by the American military and the CIA for intelligence gathering and to strike high-value targets.
Operators say the aircraft's cameras are powerful enough to determine whether a man on the ground is armed.
There have been well-publicised missed opportunities too. The Taliban leader Mullah Omar was caught in a Predator's sights but escaped when permission to fire was delayed.
Osama bin Laden is believed to have been sighted by a Predator camera in 2000 but the craft were not armed until February 2001. Other strikes have caused multiple civilian casualties, even if they hit their targets.
The American decision to share one of its most treasured and secret military assets is an extraordinary testament to the intimate and largely unseen special relationship with the British Armed Forces.
About one in seven military Predator flights is now flown by members of the 45-man RAF-dominated unit, while British servicemen hold many of the key roles in the two joint Predator squadrons and are lavishly praised by American commanders.
One commander said: "From day one, the British have sent their best - and it has shown. They perform at or above the level of everyone else."
At first sight, there is little to indicate that the Nellis base is involved in the gritty reality of live operations over the battlefields of Asia and the Middle East.
It is located in a sprawling complex in the unremarkable suburbs of America's capital of fantasy. Security is unobtrusive to the point of near-invisibility. Bland low-rise buildings and their vivid green lawns suggest a country club rather than combat.
Sqn Leader Bird said the strange surroundings made extreme concentration a key requirement when flying Predators. While the Predator crews are invulnerable, the ground troops they work with are not.
"You have to work very, very hard to keep that focus and remember that for the guys on the ground mistakes can cost lives."
Sitting side by side in dark, air-conditioned cabins, the pilot and sensor operator have to interpret activity in terrain as varied as the deserts and towns of Iraq and the mountains of Afghanistan.
Surrounded by technological wizardry that includes flight controls, maps and computer screens, it would be easy to drift.
Sgt Mac Mackenzie, 41, an Army sensor operator who has served in Northern Ireland and Iraq, said: "It is not always appreciated that this is what we have to do. You are just staring at the screen. Then suddenly it can go live, you're involved in an engagement, a target appears and everything is turned on its head."
Minutes later, a 12-hour shift may end and the men find themselves stepping into the desert, a one-second transition from Iraq to Nevada.
The British crews acknowledge that there is an air of unreality about their work, "staring at a screen for hours, watching what is happening then walking out into the heat" before driving home to their families in the suburbs of Vegas. Time off is generally spent among the bizarre architecture of the city centre, where fake pyramids, castles and the "Eiffel Tower" vie in multi-coloured capitalist anarchy for the attention of armies of gamblers.
British crews have been based at Nellis for two years, in which time some of the missile strikes have attracted headlines. But more than 90 per cent of their work is the collection of intelligence.
They spend "a significant amount" of time on special forces operations but have also tracked down guerrilla commanders, scouted ahead of convoys, sighted ambushes and rescued coalition troops who have become separated from their units.
The Predator is little more than a snowmobile engine strapped to a glider. It barely accelerates over 100mph but it flies at up to 25,000ft.
It carries a cargo of cameras, heat sensors and missiles that provide "a God's-eye view" of the battlefield, day and night. It also has extraordinary endurance, being able to stay aloft for 20 hours or more.
For many coalition ground commanders, that capability is so important that critical military operations are sometimes postponed until a Predator becomes available.
The joint manning of Predator has caused some tensions. British commanders in Iraq have complained that they are given too little of the aircraft's time despite the British presence at Nellis and the RAF, the Army and the Royal Navy men have had to make adjustments.
While personnel apply British rules of engagement and wear British uniforms, they fly American aircraft, use American communications equipment and wear American squadron flashes.
Chief Technician Gary Smith said: "We have been here so long that now we are training the Americans.
"Sometimes when you give their lads an order, you can see them stopping and wondering, 'Do I have to do this?'"
Opening 1115 Flight's doors to a news organisation for the first time, the unit commander, Sqn Ldr Andy Bird, told The Daily Telegraph that British crews had "engaged targets" six times and had inflicted casualties.
Many of the operational details are classified but RAF officers showed grainy video footage from one operation in which a Hellfire missile is seen striking a building used by an Iraqi sniper lying in wait for targets among coalition forces. The gunman was killed.
Another video showed the final moments of an Iraqi who was trying to set up a roadside bomb.
The 700 Predators, which are the size of a light aircraft, are based at airfields in faraway war zones but are piloted using satellite links from cabins at Nellis Air Force Base, on the outskirts of Las Vegas.
The aircraft, coated in bullet-proof kevlar material and nearly invisible to radar, has rapidly become one of the most valued weapons in modern warfare, giving commanders the ability to spy on an unsuspecting enemy and launch attacks on him.
It is viewed by admirers as a pin-up in the war on terrorism and has been used innumerable times by the American military and the CIA for intelligence gathering and to strike high-value targets.
Operators say the aircraft's cameras are powerful enough to determine whether a man on the ground is armed.
There have been well-publicised missed opportunities too. The Taliban leader Mullah Omar was caught in a Predator's sights but escaped when permission to fire was delayed.
Osama bin Laden is believed to have been sighted by a Predator camera in 2000 but the craft were not armed until February 2001. Other strikes have caused multiple civilian casualties, even if they hit their targets.
The American decision to share one of its most treasured and secret military assets is an extraordinary testament to the intimate and largely unseen special relationship with the British Armed Forces.
About one in seven military Predator flights is now flown by members of the 45-man RAF-dominated unit, while British servicemen hold many of the key roles in the two joint Predator squadrons and are lavishly praised by American commanders.
One commander said: "From day one, the British have sent their best - and it has shown. They perform at or above the level of everyone else."
At first sight, there is little to indicate that the Nellis base is involved in the gritty reality of live operations over the battlefields of Asia and the Middle East.
It is located in a sprawling complex in the unremarkable suburbs of America's capital of fantasy. Security is unobtrusive to the point of near-invisibility. Bland low-rise buildings and their vivid green lawns suggest a country club rather than combat.
Sqn Leader Bird said the strange surroundings made extreme concentration a key requirement when flying Predators. While the Predator crews are invulnerable, the ground troops they work with are not.
"You have to work very, very hard to keep that focus and remember that for the guys on the ground mistakes can cost lives."
Sitting side by side in dark, air-conditioned cabins, the pilot and sensor operator have to interpret activity in terrain as varied as the deserts and towns of Iraq and the mountains of Afghanistan.
Surrounded by technological wizardry that includes flight controls, maps and computer screens, it would be easy to drift.
Sgt Mac Mackenzie, 41, an Army sensor operator who has served in Northern Ireland and Iraq, said: "It is not always appreciated that this is what we have to do. You are just staring at the screen. Then suddenly it can go live, you're involved in an engagement, a target appears and everything is turned on its head."
Minutes later, a 12-hour shift may end and the men find themselves stepping into the desert, a one-second transition from Iraq to Nevada.
The British crews acknowledge that there is an air of unreality about their work, "staring at a screen for hours, watching what is happening then walking out into the heat" before driving home to their families in the suburbs of Vegas. Time off is generally spent among the bizarre architecture of the city centre, where fake pyramids, castles and the "Eiffel Tower" vie in multi-coloured capitalist anarchy for the attention of armies of gamblers.
British crews have been based at Nellis for two years, in which time some of the missile strikes have attracted headlines. But more than 90 per cent of their work is the collection of intelligence.
They spend "a significant amount" of time on special forces operations but have also tracked down guerrilla commanders, scouted ahead of convoys, sighted ambushes and rescued coalition troops who have become separated from their units.
The Predator is little more than a snowmobile engine strapped to a glider. It barely accelerates over 100mph but it flies at up to 25,000ft.
It carries a cargo of cameras, heat sensors and missiles that provide "a God's-eye view" of the battlefield, day and night. It also has extraordinary endurance, being able to stay aloft for 20 hours or more.
For many coalition ground commanders, that capability is so important that critical military operations are sometimes postponed until a Predator becomes available.
The joint manning of Predator has caused some tensions. British commanders in Iraq have complained that they are given too little of the aircraft's time despite the British presence at Nellis and the RAF, the Army and the Royal Navy men have had to make adjustments.
While personnel apply British rules of engagement and wear British uniforms, they fly American aircraft, use American communications equipment and wear American squadron flashes.
Chief Technician Gary Smith said: "We have been here so long that now we are training the Americans.
"Sometimes when you give their lads an order, you can see them stopping and wondering, 'Do I have to do this?'"
TWA 800: 10 years later, feds' coverup story still suspect By Capt. Ray Lahr
What really happened on the evening of July 17, 1996, off the shore of Long Island?
With sincere apologies to those who may not wish to be reminded, this is what I believe happened.
On a pleasant summer evening, TWA 800 was making a normal climb on its flight to Paris. At about 13,800 feet, it was hit by one or two missiles. A missile ignited the CWT (center fuel tank). The explosion blew off the nose section, ruptured the front wing spar (which is also the front of the CWT), and broke the keel beam that runs under the bottom of the CWT. The wing separated and the aircraft fell in two flaming balls, each ball fed by the fuel from the separated wing.
Does this sound at odds with the CIA/NTSB scenario that says that a spark of unknown origin ignited the CWT and blew off the nose, and that the crippled aircraft then made a zoom-climb that the eyewitnesses mistook as a missile? Yes, in my opinion there was no zoom-climb. However, a missile was politically unacceptable, so the CIA invoked the zoom-climb in a desperate attempt to dismiss the missile seen by the eyewitnesses.
US Propaganda in Iraq: Bullshit Manufactured by Bush & Co. by Christopher Brauchli

All propaganda has to be popular and has to adapt its spiritual level to the perception of the least intelligent of those towards whom it intends to direct itself. -- Adolf Hitler, Mein KampfIt keeps coming up roses. Now the roses are being fertilized by manure manufactured by Bush & Co. instead of fertilizer purchased from outside sources.
In 2005 we learned that the administration paid a group known as the Lincoln group $5 million for manure. The Lincoln Group is an American company that is paid for putting out favorable news about the war in Iraq to the Iraqi people who, seeing their friends and neighbors being blown up daily, might otherwise think things were not going well. Here is how it works.
The Pentagon has something called a "storyboard". It is literary fertilizer prepared by the Pentagon and given to the Lincoln Group that then translates the text into Arabic and disseminates it in Iraq under the by-lines of Iraqi writers thus causing it to look like homegrown manure instead of Pentagon offal. That was only one example of propaganda disseminated by the administration.
In 2005 it was disclosed that Armstrong Williams, a conservative television personality, accepted $240,000 from the administration to spread fertilizer on the airways to grow the perception the "No Child Left Behind Act" was a success. The Department of Health and Human Services paid Maggie Gallagher and Mike McMannus to promote the Healthy Marriage Initiative on the airwaves. Now we have learned that the administration has started producing and distributing its own fertilizer.
According to a story by Al Kamen in the Washington Post in early May, the Department of Agriculture (for whom fertilizer creation and spreading is second nature) has begun issuing talking points to its employees that are designed to create a favorable impression among listeners as to how the war in Iraq is going. According to Mr. Kamen an e-mail containing the talking points was sent to about 60 undersecretaries, assistant secretaries and other political appointees giving them suggested language they could insert in speeches to remind people how well things in Iraq are going.
The talking points can be viewed at washingtonpost.com/fedpage but for those of you who can’t be bothered to go there to look them up here is an example of how they might be used. This is of course just my idea and people in the USDA will certainly come up with their own examples.
If an undersecretary were invited to go to Ault, Colorado, in order to address a group of 10 year-olds at a Future Farmers of America meeting, instead of starting right out by discussing the role of the family farm in America and why the administration wants to repeal the federal estate tax to protect the family farm so the 10-year olds will have a place to work when they grow up, the speaker would begin by saying: "Several topics I'd like to talk about today-Farm Bill, [your role as future leaders of your community], trade with Japan, WTO, avian flu, animal ID-but before I do, let me touch on a subject people always ask me about. . . progress in Iraq." The speaker then spends a few minutes reading from the script describing all the wonderful things the USDA is doing in Iraq even if it isn't. The speaker describes a November visit by Secretary Johanns with Iraq's Minister of Agriculture and how impressed he was with the minister’s optimism. (Since that visit more than 325 U.S. service people have been killed and since the end of December more than 4,168 Iraqis have been killed.) The speaker then goes on saying: "The Iraqis have also discussed specific products, like tomatoes, which they are anxious to export into the world community." That is the sort of uplifting sentiment that will have the Future Farmers sitting on the edges of their chairs.
The Department of Agriculture speaker is not, of course, limited to talking about agricultural fertilizer. Another talking point discusses civil rights and is an especially moving piece. It starts out explaining that our democracy has evolved for two hundred thirty years and we’re still working to become a more perfect union. The speaker then goes on to say that "before I begin talking about the civil rights climate at USDA, (a topic that most listeners had probably never thought would be addressed in a speech given by someone from the USDA) I'd like to address the situation in another nation that is just now forging the path to democracy." And with that, the speaker is off and running telling the 10-year olds about how well things are going in Iraq.
If any of my readers thinks that the fertilizer that is thus being spread by the USDA speakers is nothing more than BS they may be right. They should keep their sentiments to themselves lest their phones get tapped.
Christopher Brauchli is a Boulder, Colorado lawyer. He can be reached at Brauchli.56@post.harvard.eduSee his website at http://humanraceandothersports.com
Morales launches Bolivia land reforms
The Bolivian president has started a land reform plan by handing over about 25,000 square kilometres of state-owned land to poor Indians.
Evo Morales marked the start of his "agrarian revolution" on Saturday, just weeks after his administration nationalised the country's natural gas industry, giving foreign-owned energy companies six months to negotiate new contracts or leave.
"We want to change Bolivia together," Morales told the thousands of Indians gathered in the eastern city of Santa Cruz to receive land titles.
"Getting back the land means we're getting back all the natural resources, we're nationalising all the natural resources."
The ceremony came after talks broke down between Morales and agribusiness leaders on his agrarian reform, which involves the distribution of 200,000 sq km of public land - an area roughly twice the size of Portugal - during the next five years.
Uncultivated land
The government is studying the redistribution of unproductive private land, while the National Farming Confederation has said it would form groups to defend land it feared could be confiscated. The government said such groups would be illegal.
The redistribution plans are heightening long-standing tensions between the prosperous residents of Bolivia's agricultural lowlands and the poorer, mostly Indian people of the western high plains.
Much of the terrain targeted for reform is uncultivated land located in the fertile eastern lowlands.
Wilson Chacaray, a Guarani Indian leader, told the crowd: "The greatest need right now is the recuperation of our territory. The landowners, the foreign companies, the political parties that have always dominated this country took our land from us and that's why we live in misery."
Alejandro Almaraz, Bolivia's vice-minister of land, said the government will ensure sustainable land management and that no forests or protected natural areas would be touched.
Handed to communities
An unspecified number of titles were handed out on Saturday to Indian communities rather than individuals.
"It's land that has no legal problems," Almaraz said. "And we believe that it's not right to try to block this measure when it's going to help many poor people that have been waiting and need this land to improve their life."
The state land was already set aside for redistribution before Morales took office in January. None of the land has been confiscated from large landholders.
But the government says it will eventually seize and redistribute privately owned land that is unproductive, was obtained illegally or is being used for speculation.
Objections
Farmers object to plans for private seizures and to the pace of the process, saying they fear that possible environmental damage from mass deforestation could harm farms already in operation.
Mauricio Roca, vice-president of the powerful Eastern Agricultural Chamber, said: "They're going to carry out a political plan for something that first requires technical structuring, infrastructure and training."
Roca said the chamber does not oppose land reform, but prefers a more gradual redistribution programme combined with agricultural training.
Agribusiness leaders said they had cut off dialogue with Morales because the government refused to make any concessions on its proposals, even as officials announced they were still open to discussing the issue.
Signing several decrees to carry out the land distribution, Morales also rescinded an unspecified amount of forestry concessions given out by Carlos Mesa, the former president.
Nearly 90% of Bolivia's productive terrain is worked by only 50,000 families, leaving millions of Bolivians with little or no land, according to the government.
You can find this article at:
http://english.aljazeera.net/NR/exeres/DCD8533A-8EF7-46D3-8520-2970CF12D1A3.htm
Evo Morales marked the start of his "agrarian revolution" on Saturday, just weeks after his administration nationalised the country's natural gas industry, giving foreign-owned energy companies six months to negotiate new contracts or leave.
"We want to change Bolivia together," Morales told the thousands of Indians gathered in the eastern city of Santa Cruz to receive land titles.
"Getting back the land means we're getting back all the natural resources, we're nationalising all the natural resources."
The ceremony came after talks broke down between Morales and agribusiness leaders on his agrarian reform, which involves the distribution of 200,000 sq km of public land - an area roughly twice the size of Portugal - during the next five years.
Uncultivated land
The government is studying the redistribution of unproductive private land, while the National Farming Confederation has said it would form groups to defend land it feared could be confiscated. The government said such groups would be illegal.
The redistribution plans are heightening long-standing tensions between the prosperous residents of Bolivia's agricultural lowlands and the poorer, mostly Indian people of the western high plains.
Much of the terrain targeted for reform is uncultivated land located in the fertile eastern lowlands.
Wilson Chacaray, a Guarani Indian leader, told the crowd: "The greatest need right now is the recuperation of our territory. The landowners, the foreign companies, the political parties that have always dominated this country took our land from us and that's why we live in misery."
Alejandro Almaraz, Bolivia's vice-minister of land, said the government will ensure sustainable land management and that no forests or protected natural areas would be touched.
Handed to communities
An unspecified number of titles were handed out on Saturday to Indian communities rather than individuals.
"It's land that has no legal problems," Almaraz said. "And we believe that it's not right to try to block this measure when it's going to help many poor people that have been waiting and need this land to improve their life."
The state land was already set aside for redistribution before Morales took office in January. None of the land has been confiscated from large landholders.
But the government says it will eventually seize and redistribute privately owned land that is unproductive, was obtained illegally or is being used for speculation.
Objections
Farmers object to plans for private seizures and to the pace of the process, saying they fear that possible environmental damage from mass deforestation could harm farms already in operation.
Mauricio Roca, vice-president of the powerful Eastern Agricultural Chamber, said: "They're going to carry out a political plan for something that first requires technical structuring, infrastructure and training."
Roca said the chamber does not oppose land reform, but prefers a more gradual redistribution programme combined with agricultural training.
Agribusiness leaders said they had cut off dialogue with Morales because the government refused to make any concessions on its proposals, even as officials announced they were still open to discussing the issue.
Signing several decrees to carry out the land distribution, Morales also rescinded an unspecified amount of forestry concessions given out by Carlos Mesa, the former president.
Nearly 90% of Bolivia's productive terrain is worked by only 50,000 families, leaving millions of Bolivians with little or no land, according to the government.
You can find this article at:
http://english.aljazeera.net/NR/exeres/DCD8533A-8EF7-46D3-8520-2970CF12D1A3.htm
Watch what OPEC does not what they say.
Many in the international and Venezuelan press are trying to trumpet the failure of the recently concluded OPEC summit to call for quota and output reductions as a setback for Venezuela and Iran. Those two countries had been warning about growing oil inventories and the risk of a price collapse unless production was cut back. But, according to most of the press, "moderates" such as Saudi Arabia had prevailed upon the organization not to cut back production in the face of still quite high oil prices. Or so it is said.
The reality of what is being done is apparently more complex as this article from page 2 of June 2nds Wall Street Journal shows:
OPEC had seemed to be in something of a pickle. Oil inventories are growing quite large and a sudden price collapse is possible. But the obvious solution of a cutback in production quotas would be a public relations disaster with oil selling at $70 per barrel. The solution? Leave quotas officially the same to assuage consumers but in reality cut back on your production. A very elegant solution by OPEC which has been completely missed by most people who are just focusing on the news about the quotas not being changed.
So while the opposition is gleefully asserting that the summit was a failure for Chavez in reality he has been getting precisely what he wanted - a price supporting production cutback. Once again we see that Chavez and OPEC are quite shrewd while the dunces that make up the opposition just don't get it. They are fixated on bombast and rhetoric while missing what is really going on behind the scenes.
The reality of what is being done is apparently more complex as this article from page 2 of June 2nds Wall Street Journal shows:
OPEC Maintains Output Targets but Trims Supply
Caracas - With oil prices still above $70 a barrel, the Organization of Petroleum Exporting Countries left its oil-output targets unchanged as expected. But behind the scenes, some major exporters already have begun making moves to effectively trim oil supply, said delegates attending the meeting.
The cartel didn't take up the hawkish call by Venezuelan President Hugo Chavez to formally cut output, set a price ceiling of "infinity" or shift the pricing of petroleum to euros instead of dollars. Qatari oil minister Abdullah bin Hamad Al-Attiyah said yesterday OPEC ministers had decided to leave output unchanged.
.....................................................
But some analysts estimate that oil supply from OPEC nations is already well below the formal output quota of 28 million barrels a day, exluding Iraq, and is running as much as one million barrelsa day less than a year ago.
.....................................................
The Saudis are producing less oil, say cartel officials. Saudi and Iranian producers, through a pricing mechanism that either encourages or discourages buyers, also have taken steps to reduce the amount of oil that reaches the market, the officals said.
...............................................
The reason for the cutbacks: While oil use is rising, global inventories are flush. This is causing concern in OPEC that if investors cut back on heavy purchases of oil futures, prices could fall precipitously. Underscoring those concerns, Saudi Oil Minister Ali Naimi said yesterday the oil market is both oversupplied and overpriced, adding that the OPEC heavyweight is seeing no extra dmeand from its customers for oil, especially the heavy crude that's more difficult to refine into fuels like gasoline.
Oil ministers are saying oil prices are being driven up by financial investors, not by fundamentals of supply and demand. "Oil could drop to $40 per barrel" if hedge and pension funds decide the price has peaked and redirect money into other markets, said one senior delegate from a major Middle Eastern country.
Such worries may seem misplaced at a time when the world economy is using up more oil. OPEC's leaders reply that they have seen oil markets turn quickly in the past. In the late 1990s, prices plunged below $11 a barrel as Asian economies tanked when inventories were high. While markets can turn on a dime, curtailing production and reducing inventory can take months.
As a result, key OPEC members are adjusting their prodution and deliveries downward to preclude further, price-threatening increases in consumer stockpiles of oil, thus preparing for the day when markets turn against them. But they are doing so quietly, because of consumer anger over high prices at the pump. As a whole, OPEC's output has fallen by about 600,000 compared with less than a year ago, at about 27.3 million barrels a day excluding Iraq, according to PFC Energy, a Washington oil-consulting company. That doesn't include oil pumped but put in storage instead of sold. Saudi Arabia, Iran, Venezuela, and Nigeria are all producing less oil than they did a year ago.
"They're starting to draw down hefty crude stocks" world-wide, said Roger Diwan, a PFC analyst, on the sidelines of the OPEC meeting. "This will position them better for any downturn in price or demand."
Some of the decline, say OPEC officials, results from an attempt by Saudi Arabia and Iran to keep world oil supplies in check. They are dong this by opting not to discount heavy, high-sulfur grades of crude oil.
OPEC had seemed to be in something of a pickle. Oil inventories are growing quite large and a sudden price collapse is possible. But the obvious solution of a cutback in production quotas would be a public relations disaster with oil selling at $70 per barrel. The solution? Leave quotas officially the same to assuage consumers but in reality cut back on your production. A very elegant solution by OPEC which has been completely missed by most people who are just focusing on the news about the quotas not being changed.
So while the opposition is gleefully asserting that the summit was a failure for Chavez in reality he has been getting precisely what he wanted - a price supporting production cutback. Once again we see that Chavez and OPEC are quite shrewd while the dunces that make up the opposition just don't get it. They are fixated on bombast and rhetoric while missing what is really going on behind the scenes.
More on George W. Bush's "Sanctity of Marriage" gay marriage constitutional ban. (Oh My!)





June 4, 2006 -- More on George W. Bush's "Sanctity of Marriage" gay marriage constitutional ban.
George W. Bush's marital problems have just taken another turn for the worse. Apparently, Mr. Bush has not only engaged in an extra-marital affair with a member of the opposite sex who is also a senior member of his Cabinet, but also a member of the same sex. WMR received the following release this morning from Leola McConnell, Democratic candidate for Governor of Nevada (who has been endorsed by WMR). McConnell is a one-time professional dominatrix.
"President Bush's speech to the nation Monday. If he doesn't say he's a gay American or at the least a bisexual one then he shouldn't be making one at all. And the notion that it would be in regards to writing bigotry into our nation's Constitution is reprehensible. Too bad it isn't me doing the rebuttal because in 1984, I watched him perform (with the enthusiasm of homosexual male who had done this many times before) a homosexual act on another man, namely Victor Ashe. Victor Ashe is the current Ambassador to the nation of Poland who should also come out like former Governor McGreevey of New Jersey and admit to being a gay American. Other homo-erotic acts were also performed by then private citizen George Bush because I performed one of them on him personally.
I am the woman this website (bushssecretlifein84.tripod.com) speaks of that has been posted on the net nearly two years now. None of this would be the business of anyone but President Bush's little ruse to save his failed presidency by using DOMA [Defense of Marriage Act] to divide Americans one from the other has to be exposed as the act of a desperate closeted homosexual man. The only crime in being GLBT is in the hiding. The President needs to come clean with the American people about his own past sexual behavior before he tries to besmirch the humanity of people in search of sincerely committing to the same bonds of matrimony he's afforded. He violated his own vows of monogamy having a homosexual affair with a long time family friend of whom his wife had no knowledge. His hypocrisy seems to know no bounds.
I had planned to run for governor of Nevada without going into any of this but his planned nationally televised address to the nation makes it necessary for me to address his attempt at division in as public a way as he picked to try this Bushification of reality regarding same sex marriages.
Sincerely,
Leola McConnell
Liberal Democratic candidate for Governor of Nevada"
---
The editor was asked what sort of relationship George W. Bush could be having with Condoleezza Rice? My reply was that it was likely aberrant and involved something like the relationship King Edward VIII had with Wallis Simpson, who was rumored to have had androgen insensitivity syndrome.
The neo-con machinations of Australian-U.S.-inspired rebellion in East Timor utilizing Opus Dei
June 4, 2006 -- More on neo-con machinations in East Timor. Australian sources report that the Australian-U.S.-inspired rebellion in East Timor was partly intended to force secular Muslim Prime Minister Mari Alkatiri from office. Information received by WMR indicates that rebel leader Major Alfredo Reinado, in addition to being supported by Australian and U.S. oil interests and Australian and U.S. intelligence operatives, is supported by anti-Muslim Roman Catholic elements that include members of the proto-fascist Catholic secretive organization Opus Dei. The Bush administration is using Opus Dei in destabilization efforts in Venezuela, Mexico, Peru, Ecuador, and Brazil. The Iberian roots of the organization and the adherence of many Spanish and Portuguese Catholics to the sect make it an ideal vehicle for stirring up problems in Spanish and Portuguese-speaking nations. East Timor is a former Portuguese colony. Opus Dei is very strong in the Liberal Party of Australia, one of the two conservative parties that make up John Howard's coalition.
Australian sources also report that the same Australian covert operatives who stirred up the rebellion in East Timor were also involved in fomenting deadly rebellions in the Solomon Islands. Next in the Australian plans are the islands of Papua New Guinea, including volatile Bougainville, Vanuatu, and Indonesian-occupied West Papua. There is a neo-con/neo-colonialist plan to virtually re-colonize the small island nations of the Pacific under the Australian flag.
Australian sources also report that the same Australian covert operatives who stirred up the rebellion in East Timor were also involved in fomenting deadly rebellions in the Solomon Islands. Next in the Australian plans are the islands of Papua New Guinea, including volatile Bougainville, Vanuatu, and Indonesian-occupied West Papua. There is a neo-con/neo-colonialist plan to virtually re-colonize the small island nations of the Pacific under the Australian flag.
Saturday, June 03, 2006
On Condi, on Dubya, and Laura (continued)

WMR can report that a Mayflower Hotel staffer has confirmed that First Lady Laura Bush spent at least one night this past week at the hotel, which is four blocks north of the White House. Mrs. Bush reportedly moved out of the White House after a confrontation with President Bush over his on-going affair with Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice. The Mayflower's official position on the story is that they can "neither confirm nor deny" the identities of their guests. Because it's penchant for security and secrecy is well known to the Secret Service, the Mayflower has become a reliable hotel for U.S. and international VIPs.
Some Washington observers believe that the recent flare up between Laura Bush and the president stems from the fact that her poll numbers are twice as favorable as her husband's (60 percent to 29 percent). Laura Bush's recent solo missions to New Orleans, Colorado, and an AIDS conference at the United Nations represent a virtual declaration of independence from the most unpopular president in U.S. history. "She's [Laura's] taking a page right out of Hillary's book," said one Washington pundit. Rice, on the other hand, has been very close and loyal to Bush since she signed on as his chief foreign policy adviser in 2000. WMR has been told of intimate encounters between Mr. Bush and Rice on trips to New York City (multiple occasions) and New Orleans following Katrina.
Mayflower officially mum on recent VIP guest and her Secret Service detail.
WMR has received numerous email from the typical right-wing political direct marketing operations with the same talking point: how dare we violate the privacy of the President and First Lady in time of war. To refresh the memory of the right, we offer this one peek into recent history:
In the GOP view of morality, Republican Presidents are entitled to more privacy than Democratic Presidents.
Feb. 18, 1998 (CNN) -- . . . Clinton also faces a divided public. In the latest CNN/USA Today/Gallup poll, 54 percent of people surveyed said they would prefer to see the Iraqi crisis resolved by diplomatic pressure and economic sanctions. Maybe more importantly, though, the poll indicated a significant drop since early February in support for military strikes against Iraq, from 50 percent to 41 percent. At the same time, by about a 2-1 margin, people say if the U.S. does attack, its goal should be remove Hussein, not just to reduce Iraq's capacity to develop weapons of mass destruction and threaten its neighbors.
And Clinton has another problem, and her name is Monica Lewinsky. In this public test of wills with Hussein, Clinton has tried to stake out the moral high ground. He has talked about "the chance to do the right thing for our children and grandchildren." But some of his political opponents think Clinton cannot claim the moral high ground, not now, not after the past month's lurid tales. As restrained as Republicans have been in discussing the Lewinsky controversy, there are signs that approach is ending.
In another bit of GOP hypocrisy, on Monday, President Bush will hold a VIP ceremony at the White House to back a bill enshrining a constitutional amendment to ban gay marriage. The name of the legislation: The Sanctity of Marriage Act. WMR hopes the mainstream TV media will focus on Laura Bush's facial reaction when Mr. Bush proclaims his support for The Sanctity of Marriage Act, i.e., if Mrs. Bush is even present for the event.
Postscript: We want to thank radio hosts Randi Rhodes and Stephanie Miller for not being cowered by the right-wing spin machine and reporting this story on their programs.
Friday, June 02, 2006
Venezuela spending billions on defense (...half as much as its neighbors on defense)
Chavez is buying guns ...
Check out this complete non-story by the Associated Press:
Venezuela spending billions on defense
Venezuela is buying helicopters, boats and military transport planes in defense deals worth about $2.7 billion, modernizing its military as tensions grow between leftist President Hugo Chavez and the United States.
Flush with oil profits but blocked from buying U.S. arms, Chavez is increasingly looking to countries like Russia and Spain as suppliers.
A cargo ship carrying 30,000 Russian-made Kalashnikov assault rifles is headed to Venezuela with the first shipment of an order totaling 100,000 guns to arrive by year's end. The military is looking to buy more submarines, and Chavez is planning an even bigger deal for Russian fighter jets.
Venezuela's defense budget is up 31 percent this year, to $2 billion, and that doesn't include roughly $2.2 billion it plans to spend for 10 transport planes and eight patrol boats on what will be Spain's largest-ever defense deal.
Got that? Venezuela is spending billions -- not millions, not hundreds of thousands -- on its military, newsworthy according to the AP.
For perspective, let's forget the U.S. and its half trillion-dollar "defense" budget, and just look around the neighborhood, shall we?
Argentina: $4.3 billion
Mexico:$6.1 billion
Colombia:$3.3 billion
Brazil:$9.4 billion
Chile$3.9 billion
What have we learned? That all the big countries of Latin America are "spending billions on defense." But I guess a headline like, "Venezuela spending half as much as its neighbors on defense" just doesn't advance the preferred storyline.
Later, the story quotes Mark Stoker of the International Institute for Strategic Studies saying: "My interpretation is that Venezuela had a certain amount of aging military equipment and needed to replace some of that." That alone should have tipped off an editor to the fact that this isn't a story at all.
Some AP readers are going to come away from the story with the disquieting feeling that Venezuela's going through a major military build-up, and I guess that's the point.
Joshua Holland is a staff writer at Alternet and a regular contributor to The Gadflyer.
Check out this complete non-story by the Associated Press:
Venezuela spending billions on defense
Venezuela is buying helicopters, boats and military transport planes in defense deals worth about $2.7 billion, modernizing its military as tensions grow between leftist President Hugo Chavez and the United States.
Flush with oil profits but blocked from buying U.S. arms, Chavez is increasingly looking to countries like Russia and Spain as suppliers.
A cargo ship carrying 30,000 Russian-made Kalashnikov assault rifles is headed to Venezuela with the first shipment of an order totaling 100,000 guns to arrive by year's end. The military is looking to buy more submarines, and Chavez is planning an even bigger deal for Russian fighter jets.
Venezuela's defense budget is up 31 percent this year, to $2 billion, and that doesn't include roughly $2.2 billion it plans to spend for 10 transport planes and eight patrol boats on what will be Spain's largest-ever defense deal.
Got that? Venezuela is spending billions -- not millions, not hundreds of thousands -- on its military, newsworthy according to the AP.
For perspective, let's forget the U.S. and its half trillion-dollar "defense" budget, and just look around the neighborhood, shall we?
Argentina: $4.3 billion
Mexico:$6.1 billion
Colombia:$3.3 billion
Brazil:$9.4 billion
Chile$3.9 billion
What have we learned? That all the big countries of Latin America are "spending billions on defense." But I guess a headline like, "Venezuela spending half as much as its neighbors on defense" just doesn't advance the preferred storyline.
Later, the story quotes Mark Stoker of the International Institute for Strategic Studies saying: "My interpretation is that Venezuela had a certain amount of aging military equipment and needed to replace some of that." That alone should have tipped off an editor to the fact that this isn't a story at all.
Some AP readers are going to come away from the story with the disquieting feeling that Venezuela's going through a major military build-up, and I guess that's the point.
Joshua Holland is a staff writer at Alternet and a regular contributor to The Gadflyer.
EXPERTS CLAIM OFFICIAL 9/11 STORY IS A HOAX
Scholars for 9/11 Truth call for verification and publication by an international consortium.
Duluth, MN (PRWEB) January 30, 2006 -- A group of distinguished experts and scholars, including Robert M. Bowman, James H. Fetzer, Wayne Madsen, John McMurtry, Morgan Reynolds, and Andreas von Buelow, have concluded that senior government officials have covered up crucial facts about what really happened on 9/11.
They have joined with others in common cause as members of "Scholars for 9/11 Truth" (S9/11T), because they are convinced, based on their own research, that the administration has been deceiving the nation about critical events in New York and Washington, D.C.
These experts suggest these events may have been orchestrated by elements within the administration to manipulate Americans into supporting policies at home and abroad they would never have condoned absent "another Pearl Harbor."
They believe that this White House is incapable of investigating itself and hope the possibility that Congress might hold an unaccountable administration accountable is not merely naive or wishful thinking.
They are encouraging news services around the world to secure scientific advice by taking advantage of university resources to verify or to falsify their discoveries. Extraordinary situations, they believe, require extraordinary measures.
If this were done, they contend, one of the great hoaxes of history would stand naked before the eyes of the world and its perpetrators would be clearly exposed, which may be the only hope for saving this nation from ever greater abuse.
They hope this might include The New York Times, which, in their opinion, has repeatedly failed to exercise the leadership expected from our nation's newspaper of record by a series of inexplicable lapses. It has failed to vigorously investigate tainted elections, lies leading to the war in Iraq, or illegal NSA spying on the American people, major unconstitutional events. In their view, The Times might compensate for its loss of stature by helping to reveal the truth about one of the great turning-point events of modern history.
Stunning as it may be to acknowledge, they observe, the government has brought but one indictment against anyone and, to the best of their knowledge, has not even reprimanded anyone for incompetence or dereliction of duty. The official conspiracy theory--that nineteen Arab hijackers under control of one man in the wilds of Afghanistan brought this about--is unsupportable by the evidential data, which they have studied. They even believe there are good reasons for suspecting that video tapes officially attributed to Osama bin Laden are not genuine.
They have found the government's own investigation to be severely flawed. The 9/11 Commission, designated to investigate the attack, was directed by Philip Zelikow, part of the Bush transition team in the NSA sector and the co-author of a book with Condoleezza Rice. A Bush supporter and director of national security affairs, he could hardly be expected to conduct an objective and impartial investigation.
They have discovered that The 9/11 Commission Report is replete with omissions, distortions, and factual errors, which David Ray Griffin has documented in his book, The 9/11 Commission Report: Omissions and Distortions. The official report, for example, entirely ignores the collapse of WTC7, a 47-story building, which was hit by no airplanes, was only damaged by a few small fires, and fell seven hours after the attack.
Here are some of the kinds of considerations that these experts and scholars find profoundly troubling:
Their own physics research has established that only controlled demolitions are consistent with the near-gravity speed of fall and virtually symmetrical collapse of all three of the WTC buildings. While turning concrete into very fine dust, they fell straight-down into their own footprints.
These experts and scholars have found themselves obliged to conclude that the 9/11 atrocity represents an instance of the approach--which has been identified by Karl Rove, the President's closest adviser--of "creating our own reality."
Duluth, MN (PRWEB) January 30, 2006 -- A group of distinguished experts and scholars, including Robert M. Bowman, James H. Fetzer, Wayne Madsen, John McMurtry, Morgan Reynolds, and Andreas von Buelow, have concluded that senior government officials have covered up crucial facts about what really happened on 9/11.
They have joined with others in common cause as members of "Scholars for 9/11 Truth" (S9/11T), because they are convinced, based on their own research, that the administration has been deceiving the nation about critical events in New York and Washington, D.C.
These experts suggest these events may have been orchestrated by elements within the administration to manipulate Americans into supporting policies at home and abroad they would never have condoned absent "another Pearl Harbor."
They believe that this White House is incapable of investigating itself and hope the possibility that Congress might hold an unaccountable administration accountable is not merely naive or wishful thinking.
They are encouraging news services around the world to secure scientific advice by taking advantage of university resources to verify or to falsify their discoveries. Extraordinary situations, they believe, require extraordinary measures.
If this were done, they contend, one of the great hoaxes of history would stand naked before the eyes of the world and its perpetrators would be clearly exposed, which may be the only hope for saving this nation from ever greater abuse.
They hope this might include The New York Times, which, in their opinion, has repeatedly failed to exercise the leadership expected from our nation's newspaper of record by a series of inexplicable lapses. It has failed to vigorously investigate tainted elections, lies leading to the war in Iraq, or illegal NSA spying on the American people, major unconstitutional events. In their view, The Times might compensate for its loss of stature by helping to reveal the truth about one of the great turning-point events of modern history.
Stunning as it may be to acknowledge, they observe, the government has brought but one indictment against anyone and, to the best of their knowledge, has not even reprimanded anyone for incompetence or dereliction of duty. The official conspiracy theory--that nineteen Arab hijackers under control of one man in the wilds of Afghanistan brought this about--is unsupportable by the evidential data, which they have studied. They even believe there are good reasons for suspecting that video tapes officially attributed to Osama bin Laden are not genuine.
They have found the government's own investigation to be severely flawed. The 9/11 Commission, designated to investigate the attack, was directed by Philip Zelikow, part of the Bush transition team in the NSA sector and the co-author of a book with Condoleezza Rice. A Bush supporter and director of national security affairs, he could hardly be expected to conduct an objective and impartial investigation.
They have discovered that The 9/11 Commission Report is replete with omissions, distortions, and factual errors, which David Ray Griffin has documented in his book, The 9/11 Commission Report: Omissions and Distortions. The official report, for example, entirely ignores the collapse of WTC7, a 47-story building, which was hit by no airplanes, was only damaged by a few small fires, and fell seven hours after the attack.
Here are some of the kinds of considerations that these experts and scholars find profoundly troubling:
- In the history of structural engineering, steel-frame high-rise buildings have never been brought down due to fires either before or since 9/11, so how can fires have brought down three in one day? How is this possible?
- The BBC has reported that at least five of the nineteen alleged "hijackers" have turned up alive and well living in Saudi Arabia, yet according to the FBI, they were among those killed in the attacks. How is this possible?
- Frank DeMartini, a project manager for the WTC, said the buildings were designed with load redistribution capabilities to withstand the impact of airliners, whose effects would be like "puncturing mosquito netting with a pencil." Yet they completely collapsed. How is this possible?
- Since the melting point of steel is about 2,700°F, the temperature of jet fuel fires does not exceed 1,800°F under optimal conditions, and UL certified the steel used to 2,000°F for six hours, the buildings cannot have collapsed due to heat from the fires. How is this possible?
- Flight 77, which allegedly hit the building, left the radar screen in the vicinity of the Ohio/Kentucky border, only to "reappear" in very close proximity to the Pentagon shortly before impact. How is this possible?
- Foreign "terrorists" who were clever enough to coordinate hijacking four commercial airliners seemingly did not know that the least damage to the Pentagon would be done by hitting its west wing. How is this possible?
- Secretary of Transportation Norman Mineta, in an underground bunker at the White House, watched Vice President Cheney castigate a young officer for asking, as the plane drew closer and closer to the Pentagon, "Do the orders still stand?" The order cannot have been to shoot it down, but must have been the opposite. How is this possible?
- A former Inspector General for the Air Force has observed that Flight 93, which allegedly crashed in Pennsylvania, should have left debris scattered over an area less than the size of a city block; but it is scattered over an area of about eight square miles. How is this possible?
- A tape recording of interviews with air traffic controllers on duty on 9/11 was deliberately crushed, cut into very small pieces, and distributed in assorted places to insure its total destruction. How is this possible?
- The Pentagon conducted a training exercise called "MASCAL" simulating the crash of a Boeing 757 into the building on 24 October 2000, and yet Condoleezza Rice, among others, has repeatedly asserted that "no one ever imagined" a domestic airplane could be used as a weapon. How is this possible?
Their own physics research has established that only controlled demolitions are consistent with the near-gravity speed of fall and virtually symmetrical collapse of all three of the WTC buildings. While turning concrete into very fine dust, they fell straight-down into their own footprints.
These experts and scholars have found themselves obliged to conclude that the 9/11 atrocity represents an instance of the approach--which has been identified by Karl Rove, the President's closest adviser--of "creating our own reality."
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
